Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-10-02 Thread the Old Topo Depot
Regarding TIGER county connectivity; since the last OSMI update GA, AL and northern MS have had county boundary issues cleaned. What's left is KY, LA, AR, southeastern TX, and portions of VA, TN, and KS. States such as ME and southeastern MA also have scattered boundaries that have not been

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-10-02 Thread Mike N
On 10/2/2012 11:15 AM, the Old Topo Depot wrote: Regarding TIGER county connectivity; since the last OSMI update GA, AL and northern MS have had county boundary issues cleaned. What's left is KY, LA, AR, southeastern TX, and portions of VA, TN, and KS. States such as ME and southeastern MA

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-10-02 Thread Alex Barth
As the Remap-a-Tron is expanding its scope beyond remapping, I'll submit Map Roulette as a new name. In case you're looking for a new name, that is :) On Oct 1, 2012, at 1:52 AM, Martijn van Exel m...@rtijn.org wrote: Also a good one. I will make a list of all the suggestions some time this

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-10-01 Thread Dale Puch
For setting up the runs, is it all SQL queries or are there other items involved? Perhaps start a wiki page for useful queries to identify problems (for this or other projects), or even just collaboration on plain text criteria ideas for future runs and build what is needed from there. Dale On

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-10-01 Thread James Umbanhowar
I was just traveling and was reminded of a Tiger problem that still hasn't been solved throughout the US-- the county line connectivity issue. It seems like a good problem for remapatron-- it is relatively discrete, but it also gives mappers the opportunity to do some additional improvement of

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-10-01 Thread Martijn van Exel
The setup involves designing the SQL queries and the initial database, and tweaking the front end for different types of problems. Up until now, we have been able to get away with just displaying the non-remapped way as a vector element on the leaflet map, but for example forfolding ways that may

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-10-01 Thread Dale Puch
Well as a start is I put a section into the QA tools page http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Quality_assurance#Remap-a-Tron Several projects there that ideas/code/SQL might be borrowed from. Well your obviously familiar with this :) did the issues found by this query all get resolved?

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-30 Thread Charlotte Wolter
Hello, John makes some excellent points. The key to making this work would be to prioritize it. Otherwise, it's a neverending Remap-a-Tron. I don't have any strong feelings about how that should be done. I'm sure someone will come up with an excellent way to do that.

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-30 Thread Mike N
On 9/30/2012 12:10 AM, Brian May wrote: And maybe have different remapatron modes, e.g. crazy tiger mode, streets with no name mode, and empty hoods mode. Yes - The empty hoods mode lends itself to importing the empty hood directly from the TIGER data. We all complain about TIGER errors,

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-30 Thread Alan Millar
Another suggestion: motorways and trunks without lanes=number tags - Alan ___ Talk-us mailing list Talk-us@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-us

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-30 Thread Alexander Jones
Alan Millar wrote: Another suggestion: motorways and trunks without lanes=number tags - Alan I'd help out with that. Alexander ___ Talk-us mailing list Talk-us@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-us

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-30 Thread Martijn van Exel
Also a good one. I will make a list of all the suggestions some time this week. There's some low hanging fruit here, and some more complex ideas. I don't know when I will have time to implement the next level, I hope to have something up before Portland. Any help is appreciated! Martijn On Sun,

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-29 Thread Nick Hocking
I think the most necessary cleanup to the USA OSM data is to clean up all the crazy unedited original Tiger roads. These can easily be identified simply as those ways that have a name but are still the original Tiger data and have not been edited. (except for the balrog-kun bot). You could just

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-29 Thread Charlotte Wolter
I also think it would be great, if we could focus on unedited TIGER. That would clean up the map a lot. There may be some technical challenges, but overal it would be a good thing. I know someone suggested roads without a name, though I think there was discussion that would be

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-29 Thread Clifford Snow
On Sep 29, 2012 10:05 AM, Charlotte Wolter techl...@techlady.com wrote: ****I also think it would be great, if we could focus on unedited TIGER. That would clean up the map a lot. There may be some technical challenges, but overal it would be a good thing. ****I know someone

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-29 Thread the Old Topo Depot
Statements that we should fix all the unedited TIGER data express a Great Idea. They are, however, rather ambitious statements, and will require more than a few weeks to completely realize. As such, cleaning up US TIGER data is a Long Term goal, and does not say anything regarding how we might

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-29 Thread Nick Hocking
oldtopos wrote I will also point out that the connectivity errors I mentioned earlier are, in fact, largely a result of unedited TIGER data I'd be happy to go along with a flavour of a connect-a-tron. It's very hard not to clean up an entire neighbourhood/s when crazy TIGER roads are spotted

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-29 Thread Brian May
On 9/29/2012 5:33 PM, the Old Topo Depot wrote: Statements that we should fix all the unedited TIGER data express a Great Idea. They are, however, rather ambitious statements, and will require more than a few weeks to completely realize. As such, cleaning up US TIGER data is a Long Term

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-28 Thread Nick Hocking
Level 3 Tiger 2012 roads, that are named, that don't have a corresponding OSM way with similar naming and similar geometry. This would pick up new 2012 Tiger roads, and unedited original Tiger named roads which were of poor quality. Level 4 Tiger unedited roads that are highway residential and

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-28 Thread Brian May
+1 Nick, maybe as a step before your suggestion. 1) New streets with no names. In Florida, there's a large number of new streets that contributors have added, but did not add a name. The TIGER 2012 overlay helps make quick work of adding these names. In many cases, streets will need to be

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-28 Thread Martijn van Exel
Nick, On Fri, Sep 28, 2012 at 12:36 AM, Nick Hocking nick.hock...@gmail.com wrote: Level 3 Tiger 2012 roads, that are named, that don't have a corresponding OSM way with similar naming and similar geometry. This would pick up new 2012 Tiger roads, and unedited original Tiger named roads

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-28 Thread Paul Norman
From: Martijn van Exel [mailto:m...@rtijn.org] Sent: Friday, September 28, 2012 8:29 AM Subject: Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3? Level 4 Tiger unedited roads that are highway residential and have no name. How many of those

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-28 Thread the Old Topo Depot
: Martijn van Exel [mailto:m...@rtijn.org] Sent: Friday, September 28, 2012 8:29 AM Subject: Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3? Level 4 Tiger unedited roads that are highway residential and have no name. How many of those are there? They would

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-28 Thread Mike N
On 9/28/2012 11:28 AM, Martijn van Exel wrote: That would be a pretty complex query, for the following reasons: * Similar naming may be obvious to a human observer, but can be really hard to detect algorithmically. * Similar geometry can be hard to detect because of split / combined ways so you

Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete! Suggestions for level 3?

2012-09-28 Thread Dale Puch
class ways get higher priority. Simple query; simple fixes. Best, On Fri, Sep 28, 2012 at 8:49 AM, Paul Norman penor...@mac.com wrote: From: Martijn van Exel [mailto:m...@rtijn.org] Sent: Friday, September 28, 2012 8:29 AM Subject: Re: [Talk-us] Remap-a-tron level 2 complete