OT: Message ID (Was: Re: 3.5.0.11 / 3.5 Postfix a preview of issues to be tested)

2005-05-23 Thread Boris Anders
Hello Gary, Gary wrote (in ): >> Just curious. Can the RFC gurus tell me if that message id format is >> legal? > Yes, it is very legal.. Very? Hm, with this IP the right part isn't unique (funny: you use the same IP than I do :-), but when you use an unique left part (wh

Re: OT: Message ID (Was: Re: 3.5.0.11 / 3.5 Postfix a preview of issues to be tested)

2005-05-23 Thread Allie Martin
Hi Boris, On 23/5/2005 11:13 PM +0200, you wrote: > Very? Hm, with this IP the right part isn't unique (funny: you use the > same IP than I do :-), TB! uses the domain name of the sender address. What if it's 'yahoo.com' or 'gmx.net'? These aren't at all unique either. :) > but when you use

Re: OT: Message ID (Was: Re: 3.5.0.11 / 3.5 Postfix a preview of issues to be tested)

2005-05-24 Thread Thomas Fernandez
Hello Allie, On Mon, 23 May 2005 16:24:26 -0500 GMT (24/05/2005, 04:24 +0700 GMT), Allie Martin wrote: AM> TB! uses the domain name of the sender address. What if it's AM> 'yahoo.com' or 'gmx.net'? These aren't at all unique either. :) To post in the usenet, you need to own an FQDN (fully-qualif

Re: OT: Message ID (Was: Re: 3.5.0.11 / 3.5 Postfix a preview of issues to be tested)

2005-05-24 Thread Tony Boom
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Hello Thomas. - --On 24 May 2005 22:27 +0700 you wrote about Re: OT: Message ID (Was: Re: 3.5.0.11 / 3.5 Postfix a preview of issues to be tested): > I'm pretty sure it doesn't and you'd be flamed in the usenet. Luckily, we >

Re: OT: Message ID (Was: Re: 3.5.0.11 / 3.5 Postfix a preview of issues to be tested)

2005-05-24 Thread Allie Martin
Hi Thomas, On 24/05/2005 10:27 PM +0700, you wrote: > It's not OT. It's about TB handles mids, and when you use TB with > MyGate to post to newsgroups, this is very on-topic. I was wondering how we came to be speaking about newsgroups and now it's clear. I don't see why TB! should follow newsg

Re: OT: Message ID (Was: Re: 3.5.0.11 / 3.5 Postfix a preview of issues to be tested)

2005-05-24 Thread Peter Palmreuther
Hello Thomas, On Tuesday, May 24, 2005 at 5:27:13 PM Thomas [TF] wrote: AM>> TB! uses the domain name of the sender address. What if it's AM>> 'yahoo.com' or 'gmx.net'? These aren't at all unique either. :) TF> To post in the usenet, you need to own an FQDN (fully-qualified domain TF> name). Yo

Re: OT: Message ID (Was: Re: 3.5.0.11 / 3.5 Postfix a preview of issues to be tested)

2005-05-25 Thread Thomas Fernandez
Hello Peter, On Tue, 24 May 2005 19:40:25 +0200 GMT (25/05/2005, 00:40 +0700 GMT), Peter Palmreuther wrote: TF>> To post in the usenet, you need to own an FQDN (fully-qualified domain TF>> name). PP> You don't. I thought I did. Mine is @thomas-bkk.my-fqdn.de. Search Google News and you'll find