[tips] Re: The attention factor (very long)

2006-04-09 Thread Lesenemis
Some comments on Michael Sylvester's “attention factor”: I have been teaching for only ten years or so, but much of what Dr. Sylvester says in his post hits me as intuitively correct. Then again, I have to wonder about some things. He writes: “The generation of students today grew up with technol

[tips] Re: [Fwd: Re: Is there evidence for the scholar practitionermodel]

2006-04-09 Thread Scott Lilienfeld
Hi Chris: Still not entirely sure what we're disagreeing about, but on a more conciliatory note, I agree wholeheatedly with your central point below. Moreover, I've seen this issue garner surprisingly little discussion in the SET literature. As an informal "existence proof" of sorts, as an und

[tips] RE: Is there evidence for the scholar practitioner model

2006-04-09 Thread Jim Clark
Hi James M. Clark Professor of Psychology 204-786-9757 204-774-4134 Fax [EMAIL PROTECTED] >>> [EMAIL PROTECTED] 08-Apr-06 12:56:03 PM >>> Am of town right now and can't access some relevant references, but if I recall correctly, the correlations between research productivity and student evaluat

[tips] Re: [Fwd: Re: Is there evidence for the scholar practitionermodel]

2006-04-09 Thread Joan Warmbold
There are a number of questions being asked here. First, do people who maintain a literacy on TOP do a better job teaching psychology? Of course, student evaluations are useful to a certain extent but there need to be other measurements, but what? And, if it is determined that reading the litera

[tips] Re: [Fwd: Re: Is there evidence for the scholar practitionermodel]

2006-04-09 Thread Christopher D. Green
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Chris: We may have to agree to disagree (respectfully, of course...) on this issue. The question before TIPS, as I understood it, was whether teachers who conduct research tend to be more better (more effective) teachers than those who don't. It is you who glossed

[tips] RE: Is there evidence for the scholar practitioner model

2006-04-09 Thread Rick Froman
Given the specificity of most research these days, anyone’s specific research is only likely to have relevance to a few parts of an undergrad class (not that some professors won’t see relevance everywhere instead of discussing the broader content). And we have all noticed how the reference

[tips] Re: The attention factor (very long)

2006-04-09 Thread mst723
Multimedia formats in the classroom, I beleive, have dramatically helpoed students learn. Some students prefer "visual" learning styles, etc. Powerpoint, which I sus in nearly every lecture, helps students organize information (which many underclassmen have a problem doing). Yes, detracts from s

[tips] RE: Is there evidence for the scholar practitioner model

2006-04-09 Thread Gary Klatsky
This looks like one of those unanswerable questions. We all seem to have personal experiences, and observations but, surprisingly, there is no empirical evidence to support either position. As Chris pointed out, being involved in a research program provides experience and insights that can be bro

[tips] Re: Is there evidence for the scholar practitioner model

2006-04-09 Thread Don Allen
Just for fun (and because I needed a break from grading term papers) I decided to do a comparison of the ratings found on Ratemyprofessor.com between our college and the local research mill (UBC). To ensure more stable ratings (and to make my task easier) I only included ratings when the prof h

The attention factor (very long)

2006-04-09 Thread msylvester
I was having a discussion with a colleague focused on the attention span of modern day student.We seem to agree that students have a short attention span.And this not only applies to K-12 students,but also true of college students today.The generation of students today grew up with technology th

Re: Is there evidence for the scholar practitioner model

2006-04-09 Thread Marie Helweg-Larsen
Another perspective to gathering useful data would be to examine it at the institutional level. For example, are institutions that promote a teacher-scholar model (what we call it as my institution) better than institutions that do not? So one fairly easy to answer question would be "do top lib

Re: [Fwd: Re: Is there evidence for the scholar practitionermodel]

2006-04-09 Thread slilien
Chris: We may have to agree to disagree (respectfully, of course...) on this issue. The question before TIPS, as I understood it, was whether teachers who conduct research tend to be more better (more effective) teachers than those who don't. The research, as least when I last looked at it, i

[Fwd: Re: Is there evidence for the scholar practitioner model]

2006-04-09 Thread Christopher D. Green
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Chris: I agree with some of what you say below, and I'm hardly an apologist for SETs (student evaluations of teaching). But I think we need to be careful not to make blanket dismisals of research, such as the one in your paragraph below. SETs have a host of methodolo

Re: Is there evidence for the scholar practitioner model

2006-04-09 Thread slilien
Chris: I agree with some of what you say below, and I'm hardly an apologist for SETs (student evaluations of teaching). But I think we need to be careful not to make blanket dismisals of research, such as the one in your paragraph below. SETs have a host of methodological shortcomings, as we

scholar-practitioner model -reply to sylvester

2006-04-09 Thread Tasha Howe
I think Michael Sylvester is a bit off here. What he describes happens for the majority of professors I know, regardless of their background. Yes, African Americans face a lot of stereotype threat issues, but all of us have fear of evaluation before tenure also, which makes us try our best in all a

Re: Is there evidence for the scholar practitioner model

2006-04-09 Thread Christopher D. Green
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:   So it's inconceivable that having other roles related to research - such as, dissertation committee work, writing or reading about current research because as a teacher one DOES value keeping up with the field, would allow a teacher to convey the excitem

Re: Artistic decline after Alzheimer's

2006-04-09 Thread Drnanjo
I heard something similar about the Dutch artist William DeKoonig. As his memory deteriorated he went through a phase of painting the most beautiful roses he'd ever done. Part of this was proposed to be due to the fact that he may have felt that he was looking at something he'd never seen bef

Artistic decline after Alzheimer's

2006-04-09 Thread sblack
Some time ago we discussed the case of the famous novelist Iris Murdoch, whose descent into Alzheimer's was portrayed in the 2001 film _Iris_ by the ineffable Judi Dench. Maloney et al last year published an interesting analysis comparing Murdoch's last work to her earlier novels, and found sub

RE: Fairy tales

2006-04-09 Thread Louis Schmier
Well, until the German dictionary that was started by the Brothers Grimm was completed, the prevailing language of the nobility and court, as in all the other Germanic states, was French. It was primarily Goethe in the 18th century who drew attention to the need for a cultural independence from

Re: Is there evidence for the scholar practitioner model

2006-04-09 Thread Drnanjo
In a message dated 4/9/2006 7:17:37 A.M. Pacific Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: My point (once again) was not that students will *enjoy* researcher-teachers better but, rather, that the kind of practical laboratory experience a researcher has makes possible a different *kind

Re: Is there evidence for the scholar practitioner model

2006-04-09 Thread Robert Wildblood
I think that Mike points out something that is very important.  For the most part, full-time, tenure track faculty spend most of their teaching time with upper-level undergraduate majors or graduate students while much of the most basic course teaching (Intro in particular) is taught by graduate st

Re: Is there evidence for the scholar practitioner model

2006-04-09 Thread Christopher D. Green
In response to Nancy, let me say that nothing I said was intended to insult or denigrate anyone. Indeed, I said it as a person who does not spend much of his own time in labs anymore. (Recently I've been spending more of my time doing historical research, a whole other kind of praxis that doesn

RE: Fairy tales

2006-04-09 Thread msylvester
Original Message From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: tips@acsun.frostburg.edu Subject: RE: Fairy tales Date: Sun, 9 Apr 2006 05:24:29 -0400 >The Grimms were scholars. In fact, they were lexicographers. Their >initial intent was to >devise a written grammar and dictionary to form a base for a

RE: Fairy tales

2006-04-09 Thread Louis Schmier
The Grimms were scholars. In fact, they were lexicographers. Their initial intent was to devise a written grammar and dictionary to form a base for a then common oral Germany language that would replace French as the dominant cultural language in the quest for a German national identity that w