Re:[tips] to deceive or not to deceive

2017-10-08 Thread David Epstein
On Sun, 8 Oct 2017, Kenneth Steele went: The rule I was taught was to answer the question of whether the participant left the session with an understanding that could produce harm to the participant. Extreme example: I tell the participant that he had ingested kool-aid when he had received kool

Re: [tips] to deceive or not to deceive

2017-10-08 Thread Kenneth Steele
The rule I was taught was to answer the question of whether the participant left the session with an understanding that could produce harm to the participant. Extreme example: I tell the participant that he had ingested kool-aid when he had received kool-aid plus alcohol (or the reverse condit

RE: [tips] to deceive or not to deceive

2017-10-08 Thread Miguel Roig
I was about to convey something similar before I saw Karl's post. Admittedly, this is a mild form of deception (would anyone really object to participating in the study because they were told that the study was of memory rather than of attention or vice versa?). The fact is that very often resea

RE: [tips] to deceive or not to deceive

2017-10-08 Thread Wuensch, Karl Louis
One of my grad students deceived subjects by telling them that the research was designed to investigate the physiology of taking online quizzes. In fact, the research involved relating physiology to cheating on such quizzes. Because of such deception, our IRB informed us that not onl

[tips] to deceive or not to deceive

2017-10-08 Thread Carol DeVolder
Good afternoon, TIPSters. I have a question regarding IRBs and informed consent. My students submitted their proposal and created a "working title" for their study that doesn't reveal their real intent (they are looking at memory rather than attention). To disclose the true nature of the study to p