Re: [5.0] fileupload 1.0 RC 1 API breakage

2003-06-05 Thread Joe Germuska
At 7:38 -0500 6/4/03, Glenn Nielsen wrote: Was this really necessary? The email below went to both the commons-dev and tomcat -dev lists. If Remy was pointing the finger at anyone, it was at his fellow Tomcat Developers. Thats how I interpreted it. Martin has been busting his tail trying to get

Re: [5.0] fileupload 1.0 RC 1 API breakage

2003-06-05 Thread David Graham
FileUpload.setRepositoryPath(String) and FileItem(String) were removed from the fileupload RC 1 release, which breaks the Tomcat 4.1.x and 5.0.x build. The first method has no apparent replacement (but I didn't try to dig around). This is clearly an unacceptable situation from the Tomcat perspe

Re: [5.0] fileupload 1.0 RC 1 API breakage

2003-06-05 Thread David Graham
One last note: IMO, as a rule (and esp in the commons), you should make every effort to avoid breaking the API between a beta and a final. FileUpload did not go final, if went to RC1. Changes between RCs and final could be considered inappropriate but not from beta to RC. See the Release Types

Re: [5.0] fileupload 1.0 RC 1 API breakage

2003-06-05 Thread Remy Maucherat
Glenn Nielsen wrote: Martin Cooper wrote: Get your own act together, Tomcat developers, before you start pointing the finger at those of us who really try hard to maintain compatibility across Jakarta projects. Was this really necessary? The email below went to both the commons-dev and tomcat -d

Re: [5.0] fileupload 1.0 RC 1 API breakage

2003-06-04 Thread Glenn Nielsen
Martin Cooper wrote: I posted a patch to the Tomcat-Dev list yesterday which should fix this problem. Apparently, nobody on the Tomcat-Dev list paid any attention to my post. The methods in question have been deprecated for some time. I have not seen the patch email on tomcat-dev. Perhaps its in t

Re: [5.0] fileupload 1.0 RC 1 API breakage

2003-06-04 Thread Bill Barker
The attached works for me (against commons-fileupload HEAD). I didn't do anything about it since I wasn't sure which version of fileupload we were targeting. - Original Message - From: "Remy Maucherat" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "Tomcat Developers List" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Jakarta Commons