Re: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-04-05 Thread UNIVERSITY*CITOYEN
Glenn moyer wrote: But one tax scheme that seems like a no-brainer to consider now, even though to Nutter, it is inviolate and can't be mentioned or considered- The ponzi scheme called the ten year tax abatement. interesting article about the tax abatement in this week's inquirer: http://

Re: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-06 Thread MLamond
In a message dated 1/6/09 6:20:20 PM, anthony_w...@earthlink.net writes: > Here in the Free Library is a fistful of millions at hand. It's a > fistful that, intuitively, might be connected to larger, well-heeled > private potential partners. Nutter made it very clear from the > beginning, even

Re: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-06 Thread Anthony West
Equitable real-estate valuation, no matter how praiseworthy, can't possibly be installed in time to balance the remainder of the 2008-09 City budget. If City Council slammed the pedal tomorrow, there's a faint possibility it could be enacted in time for the 2009-10 budget that will kick in next

RE: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-06 Thread KAREN ALLEN
Dear List: I was going to write a long reasoned response to to this below, but instead, I'll give it the answer it deserves: "Whaddaya mean the list is your playground and you get to make the rules as to who can play and what they can say??? I can play on it too!!! Whaddaya mean that you c

Re: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-06 Thread Dave Axler
Seems to me that, while a number of good points have been made already, a few things have been omitted or glossed over... 1) A revenue-neutral approach is a possibility. A city-wide reappraisal would be combined with a change to the millage rate for real-estate tax, so that the total income

Fwd: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-06 Thread pmuyehara
implemented. Paul -Original Message- From: KAREN ALLEN To: UnivCity Listserv Sent: Mon, 5 Jan 2009 5:38 pm Subject: RE: [UC] Taxation and the libraries The danger to longterm homeowners comes from any law that bases real estate taxes on sale price or "

Re: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-05 Thread MLamond
In a message dated 1/5/09 5:39:54 PM, kallena...@msn.com writes: > If the constant in my examples above were livable space and lot size,  > "equalization between neighborhoods" could occur. Homeowners in Center City > would pay substantially less than the homeowners in Northwest > Philadelp

RE: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-05 Thread KAREN ALLEN
The danger to longterm homeowners comes from any law that bases real estate taxes on sale price or "value", because as Melani is surely aware, a lot of factors determines "value". The "equalization between neighborhoods" that Melani mentioned cannot be done if the standard being used is purchas

Re: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-05 Thread Glenn moyer
estroy the libraries? Glenn You can fool some people some time, but you can't fool all the people all the time, Bob Marley     -Original Message- From: mlam...@aol.com Sent: Jan 5, 2009 10:55 AM To: glen...@earthlink.net, univcity@list.purple.com Subject: Re: [UC] Taxation and the librarie

Re: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-05 Thread MLamond
In a message dated 1/5/09 3:22:36 PM, briansi...@gmail.com writes: > But since the point is to soften the impact of the new tax rates on > homeowners, how about this. When the new tax rates are established, > we'll know what the Old and New taxes would be for any given property, > right? If th

Re: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-05 Thread Brian Siano
mlam...@aol.com wrote: Your ideas for different systems of taxation are interesting, Brian & Karen, but not currently legal; PA law says that these taxes must be _equal_. The problem is that they are NOT equal right now; the city is breaking the law. The City is required by law to assess ever

Re: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-05 Thread MLamond
In a message dated 1/5/09 12:18:43 AM, briansi...@gmail.com writes: how about this for a solution?for _primary residences_, people's _homes_... apply the new tax standard only to properties purchased after the date the tax standards take effect.  This way, current homeowners won't have

RE: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-05 Thread KAREN ALLEN
"[I}f the City were collecting the same amount from everybody whose house has the same value...", If the city were to collect the same amount from everybody whose house has the same value, the City would have legions of people who would be forced to move because they could no longer afford to

Re: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-05 Thread MLamond
Glenn, I totally agree that straightening out the ridiculous tax assessment situation will not happen in time to help the libraries. I don't understand why Nutter doesn't back down and say "the people have spoken; we'll have to find that $8 million somewhere else and keep the libraries ope

Re: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-05 Thread Glenn moyer
the mayor. "The people, united, will never be defeated!" Your comrade, Glenn -Original Message- From: mlam...@aol.com Sent: Jan 5, 2009 12:05 AM To: pf...@ccat.sas.upenn.edu, univcity@list.purple.com Subject: Re: [UC] Taxation and the libraries In a message dated 1/3/09 7:20:3

Re: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-04 Thread MLamond
In a message dated 1/3/09 7:20:36 PM: > ...While the fact that the city needs additional revenue is obvious, any > changes to the  property tax structure have to be made with careful > deliberation as to the consequences of dramatic increases... > Agreed, totally - and remember, I also wrote: .

RE: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-04 Thread Glenn moyer
want to ignore the good qualities that sometimes pop out from the real Melani inside.   Thanks again for discussing the actual taxation idea.   Glenn -Original Message- From: KAREN ALLEN Sent: Jan 3, 2009 7:19 PM To: UnivCity Listserv Subject: RE: [UC] Taxation and the libraries Glenn

RE: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-03 Thread KAREN ALLEN
on money the taxpayer actually has.No one wants to be forced to sell their house because they can't afford to live in it anymore. Date: Sat, 3 Jan 2009 18:09:01 -0500From: glen...@earthlink.netto: mlam...@aol.com; univc...@list.purple.comsubject: Re: [UC] Taxation and the libraries It&#

Re: [UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-03 Thread Glenn moyer
Original Message- From: mlam...@aol.com Sent: Jan 3, 2009 1:57 PM To: UnivCity@list.purple.com, pf...@ccat.sas.upenn.edu Subject: [UC] Taxation and the libraries The fate of the 11 libraries is now before City Council.  Mayor Nutter had to make some tough decisions to balance the City's budget

[UC] Taxation and the libraries

2009-01-03 Thread MLamond
The fate of the 11 libraries is now before City Council. Mayor Nutter had to make some tough decisions to balance the City's budget, and the library closing choice seems to have been a particularly poor one. But, Mayor Nutter is not the villain here. Our city's tax structure is a more lik