Re: Is struts more performant than JSF

2005-05-12 Thread Frank W. Zammetti
On Thu, May 12, 2005 6:46 am, Ted Husted said: > If the decision between approaches is not obvious, then do the first > interation of your application using both, and compare the results for > yourself. I don't know what kind of environment you work in, but if I suggested writing an application tw

Re: Is struts more performant than JSF

2005-05-12 Thread Ted Husted
On 5/10/05, Yan Hu <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Hi: > I have been playing with JSF lately. I really like it since it is very > intuitive. But as I > understand it, JSF keeps a component tree for each page with JSF widgets in > it on the server. So > it is heavy weight compared with struts. Coul

Re: Is struts more performant than JSF

2005-05-11 Thread Dakota Jack
The JSF is an event-based framework with tight coupling in a page-based controller. That should answer the question in itself. If you want that, then you will put up with the performance and CPU hit. You might even put up with the performance and CPU hit if you are hell bent on using tools inste

Re: Is struts more performant than JSF

2005-05-11 Thread Craig McClanahan
On 5/10/05, Yan Hu <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Hi: > I have been playing with JSF lately. I really like it since it is very > intuitive. But as I > understand it, JSF keeps a component tree for each page with JSF widgets in > it on the server. So > it is heavy weight compared with struts. Coul

Re: Is struts more performant than JSF

2005-05-11 Thread Adam Hardy
On 11/05/05 00:15 Matt Raible wrote: You could hammer on AppFuse and Equinox - they both have Struts and JSF versions. http://demo.appfuse.org/appfuse (Struts 1.2.4) http://demo.appfuse.org/appfuse-jsf (MyFaces 1.0.7) http://demo.raibledesigns.com/equinox-struts (same versions as above) http://de

Re: Is struts more performant than JSF

2005-05-10 Thread Matt Raible
On May 10, 2005, at 4:48 PM, Jesse Alexander (KBSA 21) wrote: Hi I think this is not an easy question. I got the impression that Struts is needing more JSP-tags to represent a page which seems to slow it down a bit. JSF uses more memory (if you use server-side state) or more bandwidth (if you use

RE: Is struts more performant than JSF

2005-05-10 Thread Jesse Alexander (KBSA 21)
Hi I think this is not an easy question. I got the impression that Struts is needing more JSP-tags to represent a page which seems to slow it down a bit. JSF uses more memory (if you use server-side state) or more bandwidth (if you use client-side state) but somehow processing seems quite opt