Re: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-Store

2019-02-11 Thread Clebert Suconic
I’m not sure what’s the issue to be honest. You should try the latest version of Artemis and you still hit an issue you would have to communicate us a way to reproduce the issue. On Mon, Feb 11, 2019 at 3:32 PM jraju wrote: > Hi, > > Any update to this issue please? > > I am also trying a Symm

RE: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-Store

2019-02-11 Thread jraju
Hi, Any update to this issue please? I am also trying a Symmetric cluster with Multi server environment where JGroups is used for discovery. The JGroup ping file is pointed to shared file location. Thanks. Raju J -- Sent from: http://activemq.2283324.n4.nabble.com/ActiveMQ-User-f2341805.html

RE: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-Store

2018-07-05 Thread Stefaniuk, Marcin
Any follow-up on that because I'm also struggling with version 2.5.0? Marcin -Original Message- From: Archibald [mailto:arch...@gmx.net] Sent: 26 April 2018 20:37 To: users@activemq.apache.org Subject: Re: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-

Re: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-Store

2018-04-26 Thread Archibald
@jbertram: 2.5.0 -- Sent from: http://activemq.2283324.n4.nabble.com/ActiveMQ-User-f2341805.html

Re: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-Store

2018-04-26 Thread Justin Bertram
What version of Artemis are you using? Justin On Thu, Apr 26, 2018 at 5:00 AM, Archibald wrote: > The more I search for answers by reading other threads the more I get the > impression, that the whole replication strategy only works on your test > cases (or single host) but not in a real clust

Re: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-Store

2018-04-26 Thread Archibald
The more I search for answers by reading other threads the more I get the impression, that the whole replication strategy only works on your test cases (or single host) but not in a real clustered (multi host) environment... See http://activemq.2283324.n4.nabble.com/H-A-colocated-replication-envi

Re: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-Store

2018-04-26 Thread Archibald
Hi Justin, After spending hours of reading through documentation and examples I finally decided to continue with the replication/colocate approach. So I've started two brokers which should pair with each other using static connectors. true 1 -1

Re: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-Store

2018-04-24 Thread Justin Bertram
> what I understood from the documentation is that with the scale-down option it should very well be possible to offload the current work to another live server (in case of normal shutdown, of course). Or am I wrong? Your understanding is correct. However, scale-down and HA are not the same thing

Re: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-Store

2018-04-24 Thread Archibald
Hi Justin, what I understood from the documentation is that with the scale-down option it should very well be possible to offload the current work to another live server (in case of normal shutdown, of course). Or am I wrong? And how's scaled down interally handled? A client currently connected t

Re: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-Store

2018-04-24 Thread Francesco Nigro
You've stolen the words from my mouth Justin :) @archibald Can just say: as he has said :) Il giorno mar 24 apr 2018 alle ore 15:04 Justin Bertram ha scritto: > > If have 3 live servers running in one cluster which do load balancing, > HA, etc. Do I really need backup servers? If one is down, I

Re: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-Store

2018-04-24 Thread Michael André Pearce
Good old politics , fair enough. Re docker I think there is such a thing now as statefulservice think it was called petservice for a while before. But essentially gives you stateful disk. But totally get your reasons, half our decisions in life is due to internal politics :) Sent from my i

Re: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-Store

2018-04-24 Thread Archibald
@MichelAndrePearce That's a valid question. And the answer is more or less politically driven. If you break down a monolith application which does everything in one transaction people are getting nervious about their data. Keeping messages within a database (which itself is also clustered and ther

Re: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-Store

2018-04-24 Thread Justin Bertram
> If have 3 live servers running in one cluster which do load balancing, HA, etc. Do I really need backup servers? If one is down, I suspect the two others to take over message processing... The issue here is that HA isn't provided between live servers. HA only works between live and backup server

Re: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-Store

2018-04-24 Thread Archibald
Hi Franz, I just checked the artemis-configuration.xsd and you're right! There's a node-manager-store-table-name specified. I was missing that in the latest documentation about the jdbc-store. So I can have multiple tables for each broker and a shared set of tables for bindings and messages? If

Re: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-Store

2018-04-24 Thread Michael André Pearce
Is there a reason you don’t look at replicates journal setup? Journal is the primary and most performant way to run, especially in a scalable way which is what multi master is about. JDBC really is just for retro users, you won’t get benefit from multi master as you will have the shared single

Re: [ARTEMIS] Clustered broker with multiple live servers and shared JDBC-Store

2018-04-24 Thread Francesco Nigro
Hi Archibald! If you want to have 3 servers running over the same shared store I think you have to choose 1 to be the live and the remaining 2 to be backups. If you want to have 3 live servers, each one with shared store HA you need to specify for each [live, backups] group a different node manag