[VIHUELA] Re: Palmer fretting

2007-11-28 Thread Martyn Hodgson
Peter, Many thanks for this - look forward to seeing it. May I though comment on one thing: when many lutenists say my lute's fretted in 'meantone' they often really only think of the first course and seem blissfully unaware that the chromatic/diatonic semitone sequence is different

[VIHUELA] Palmer fretting

2007-11-28 Thread Peter Forrester
Dear Alexander and All, Alexander's discovery of so many ET positions apparent in the fret measurements accompanying the museum plan of the Palmer orpharion has prompted me to produce a drawing which perhaps better illustrates the meantone nature of the fingerboard. I also possess another drawing

[VIHUELA] Re: Palmer orpharion images

2007-11-28 Thread Martyn Hodgson
Thanks for this. I would tune the open strings in relation to each other and not by using the fingerboard which would be rather begging the question. I believe this sort of analysis is extremely valuable especially since many (not you of course) who claim to use some form of 'meantone' tuni