It's safe now to exhale...
I think Lex is trying to argue that the "French" tuning originated with
Carre and Corbetta just copied it because he thought this would make his
music more acceptable to French players although it wasn't the tuning he
used himself.
Almost. I try to argue that the
. I'm still holding mine for the revelation of the principal
issue..
MH
From: Roman Turovsky
To: Martyn Hodgson ; Monica Hall
Cc: Vihuelalist
Sent: Tuesday, 6 September 2011, 17:02
Subject: [VIHUELA] Re: Carre 'Anche' - etc.
I knew I sh
I knew I shouldn't have held my breath
RT
From: "Monica Hall"
One other small point - I said
To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html
I think Lex is trying to argue that the "French" tuning originated with
Carre and Corbetta just copied it because he thought this would make his
music more acceptable to French players although it wasn't the tuning he
used himself.
One other small point - I said
"Ms.Rés. 2344 which is dated
I think Roman is right. I have spent enough time on this already and we
have been over it all so many times in the past.
There is really nothing more I wish to say.
Monica
- Original Message -
From: "Roman Turovsky"
To: "Martyn Hodgson" ; "Monica Hall"
; "Lex Eisenhardt"
Cc: "V
Only the European Court at he Hague knows the principal issue here, and it
issued a gag order apropos.
RT
- Original Message -
From: "Martyn Hodgson"
To: "Monica Hall" ; "Lex Eisenhardt"
Cc: "Vihuelalist"
Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2011 10:38 AM
Subject: [VIHUELA] Re: Carre 'Anc
Hello you two,
I've been away a couple of days: can you kindly remind me of the
principal issue in this latest exchange? It surely can't be that you
aim to base an entire case on Carre's book
rgds
Martyn
From: Monica Hall
To: Lex Eisenhardt
Cc: Vihuelalist
Sent:
There was a market for publishing guitar music in mixed style in Italy,
from 1630 on. Not in France.
How do you know? It may be that due to the economic situation in
France -
especially during the Fronde - that it wasn't practical to print music but
that
doesn't prove that players were not
February 1671 indeed. We know that the printing of Corbetta's book was
completed 31 October 1671. We don't know what he has changed or added
between September 1670 and October 1671.
I think it unlikely that Corbetta would have changed anything after being
granted the licences because publicati
Who from France studied guitar in Italy?
In the introduction to his 1640 book Carbonchi says
"Requests made by various scholars, particularly German, French and English
gentlemen, made me decide to publish the present French tablature hoping in
this way to be more helpful to French players and
As I have explained several times the licences of Corbetta's La guitarre
royale are dated September 1670 which means that he had assembled the book
and was seeking permission to publish it.Carre was not granted a
licence
until 1671.
February 1671 indeed. We know that the printing of Corbet
plagiarism?
That is the most obvious explanation although there could be others. I
think very little of Carre's work is original.
I don't think there is much doubt that Corbetta's book is earlier than
Carre's.
I don't see why we should believe that.
As I have explained several times th
12 matches
Mail list logo
