Re: [WikiEN-l] Rules on WP, was Re: Talk pages Considered Harmful (for references)

2011-12-27 Thread Ken Arromdee
On Fri, 23 Dec 2011, Charles Matthews wrote: >> And the more you use "it's in the >> rules" as a club to hit bad users with, the more others can use it as a >> club >> to force bad ideas through; there's just no defense to "what I want >> follows the >> rules". You see this all the time for BLPs:

Re: [WikiEN-l] Rules on WP, was Re: Talk pages Considered Harmful (for references)

2011-12-24 Thread Ray Saintonge
On 12/23/11 7:27 AM, Charles Matthews wrote: > On 22 December 2011 18:10, Ken Arromdee wrote: > >> And the more you use "it's in the >> rules" as a club to hit bad users with, the more others can use it as a >> club to force bad ideas through; there's just no defense to "what I want >> follows the

[WikiEN-l] Rules on WP, was Re: Talk pages Considered Harmful (for references)

2011-12-23 Thread Charles Matthews
On 22 December 2011 18:10, Ken Arromdee wrote: > > And for the general problem is something I've often noted: Wikipedia is set > up to force people to follow the rules. Interesting debating point, but I think the comment is ahistorical. It is more accurate, IMO, to note that "slavish" rule-foll