Hi,
I found this
webhttp://www.bjinstitute.org/newsmessage/reprostationen-des-bj-institutes-fuer-wikipedia/10a20af93816783eefe8480b92b9f042/
page
on the web site of BJ Institute.
Problem : This image is a CC By SA photography on Commons and the credit is
wrong (good credit : Charles Andrès - CC
The credit is not wrong, but possibly somewhat incomplete. As you well know,
much of the content of Wikimedia has more than one author and it is common
knowledge that all of the content of Wikimedia is published as CC-BY-SA or
GFDL. In the case of many authors attribution is often difficult.
To cite another example:
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Rencontres_Wikimedia_France_-_Intervention_de_Ludovic_P%C3%A9ron.JPG
states clearly, that the license is CC-BY-SA, but – very unfortunately indeed –
it does not unambiguously attribute the authorship!! Or does “user” mean
I think we're not talking about the same pictures.
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Herbarium_Neuch%C3%A2tel,_Ludovic_P%C3%A9ron_num%C3%A9risant_des_planches.jpg
It's Charles Andrès the author of this one.
Ludovic
2013/10/16 Hartwig Thomas hartwig.tho...@enterag.ch
Sorry, I did not
No.
If i save the picture on my computer, I don't see these EXIF.
2013/10/16 Hartwig Thomas hartwig.tho...@enterag.ch
In that case, there is nothing to worry about! The picture on Brunos
website contains the same metadata and therefore contains the attribution!
Hartwig
** **
Did you notice, that the scanning station on the picture was invented and built
by Bruno with his own mind and hands and made available to Wikipedia for free?
Did Charles Andrès ask his permission to publish a photograph of it? Did he
attribute its author correctly? Does he work for Wikimedia
On 16/10/13 13:39, Hartwig Thomas wrote:
Sorry, I did not see the word author. So the file should be attributed to
Thesupermat, not to Charles Andrès.
I think you are mixing up the images; the images you cite in the email
below was created by Thesupermat, as indicated.
The original image
Thomas,
The reprostation on this picture is the first one of this project. So the
creator of this reprostation is not Burno, it's *me*.
Ludovic
2013/10/16 Hartwig Thomas hartwig.tho...@enterag.ch
Did you notice, that the scanning station on the picture was invented and
built by Bruno with
On my computer, I do see it. (Windows 7, Windows Explorer, down below ...)
Besides, Bruno can hardly be responsible for what YOU can or cannot do!
Hartwig
From: wikimediach-l-boun...@lists.wikimedia.org
[mailto:wikimediach-l-boun...@lists.wikimedia.org] On Behalf Of Ludovic Péron
Sent:
2013/10/16 Hartwig Thomas hartwig.tho...@enterag.ch
The credit is not wrong, but possibly somewhat incomplete.
It's not incomplete, it's non existent. It names the repository instead of
the source, the author is not mentioned, let's not even talk about the
license (which, I admit, is the
Not true! You may have built it. The „Creator“ of the intellectual property was
Bruno!
Hartwig
From: wikimediach-l-boun...@lists.wikimedia.org
[mailto:wikimediach-l-boun...@lists.wikimedia.org] On Behalf Of Ludovic Péron
Sent: Wednesday, October 16, 2013 1:50 PM
To: Wikimedians in
I shall quit participating in Wikimedia. I cannot stand people with that kind
of attitude.
Hartwig
From: wikimediach-l-boun...@lists.wikimedia.org
[mailto:wikimediach-l-boun...@lists.wikimedia.org] On Behalf Of Fanny Schertzer
Sent: Wednesday, October 16, 2013 1:53 PM
To: Wikimedians in
2013/10/16 Hartwig Thomas hartwig.tho...@enterag.ch
Did you notice, that the scanning station on the picture was invented and
built by Bruno with his own mind and hands and made available to Wikipedia
for free? Did Charles Andrès ask his permission to publish a photograph of
it? Did he
On 16/10/13 13:47, Hartwig Thomas wrote:
Did you notice, that the scanning station on the picture was invented
and built by Bruno with his own mind and hands and made available to
Wikipedia for free? Did Charles Andrès ask his permission to publish
a photograph of it? Did he attribute its
2013/10/16 Hartwig Thomas hartwig.tho...@enterag.ch
I have had my cup of tea. I still consider people despicable who do not
recognize, that someone has spent weeks and weeks for no money whatsoever
to further the common good. A nice private notice or question to Bruno
would have been
Thomas,
Please, see the medata of the
filehttp://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Herbarium_Neuch%C3%A2tel,_Ludovic_P%C3%A9ron_num%C3%A9risant_des_planches.jpg,
look the date of the picture : 29 June 2012
WMCH bought the Bruno's reprostation in december 2012
So, it's really complected to
Following Gabriel's email, I take this opportunity to inform you about the
Wikimedia CH Education Program,
This program aims to support the usage of Wikipedia in Classroom, it can be by
being present in the class with the teacher, or by helping Wikimedians who
already have programs in class.
17 matches
Mail list logo
