Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris better Than Solaris10u6 with requards to ARECA Raid Card

2009-01-16 Thread Charles Wright
I tested with zfs_vdev_max_pending=8 I hoped this should make the error messages arcmsr0: too many outstanding commands (257 256) go away but it did not. zfs_vdev_max_pending=8 this should have only allowed 128 commands total to be outstanding I would think (16 Drives * 8 = 128). However

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris better Than Solaris10u6 with requards to ARECA Raid Card

2009-01-15 Thread Charles Wright
I've tried putting this in /etc/system and rebooting set zfs:zfs_vdev_max_pending = 16 Are we sure that number equates to a scsi command? Perhaps I should set it to 8 and see what happens. (I have 256 scsi commands I can queue across 16 drives) I still got these error messages in the log. Jan

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris better Than Solaris10u6 with requards to ARECA Raid Card

2009-01-15 Thread Richard Elling
Charles Wright wrote: I've tried putting this in /etc/system and rebooting set zfs:zfs_vdev_max_pending = 16 You can change this on the fly, without rebooting. See the mdb command at:

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris better Than Solaris10u6 with requards to ARECA Raid Card

2009-01-14 Thread Johan Hartzenberg
There is an update in build 105, but it is only pertaining to the Raid Management tool: Issues Resolved: BUG/RFE:6776690http://bugs.opensolaris.org/bugdatabase/view_bug.do?bug_id=6776690Areca raid management util doesn't work on solaris Files Changed:

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris better Than Solaris10u6 with requards to ARECA Raid Card

2009-01-14 Thread Charles Wright
Thanks for the info.I'm running the Latest Firmware for my card: V1.46 with BOOT ROM Version V1.45 Could you tell me how you have your card configured? Are you using JBOD, RAID, or Pass Through? What is your Max SATA mode set too? How may drives do you have attached? What is your ZFS

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris better Than Solaris10u6 with requards to ARECA Raid Card

2009-01-14 Thread Charles Wright
Here's an update: I thought that the error message arcmsr0: too many outstanding commands might be due to a Scsi queue being over ran The areca driver has #*define*ARCMSR_MAX_OUTSTANDING_CMD http://src.opensolaris.org/source/s?defs=ARCMSR_MAX_OUTSTANDING_CMD256 What might be

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris better Than Solaris10u6 with requards to ARECA Raid Card

2009-01-14 Thread Richard Elling
Charles Wright wrote: Here's an update: I thought that the error message arcmsr0: too many outstanding commands might be due to a Scsi queue being over ran Rather than messing with sd_max_throttle, you might try changing the number of iops ZFS will queue to a vdev. IMHO this is

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris better Than Solaris10u6 with requards to ARECA Raid Card

2009-01-14 Thread James C. McPherson
Just to let everybody know, I'm in touch with Charles and we're working on this problem offline. We'll report back to the list when we've got something to talk about. James On Wed, 14 Jan 2009 08:37:44 -0800 (PST) Charles Wright char...@asc.edu wrote: Here's an update: I thought that the

[zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris better Than Solaris10u6 with requards to ARECA Raid Card

2009-01-13 Thread Charles Wright
Under Solaris 10 u6 , No matter how I configured my ARECA 1261ML Raid card I got errors on all drives that result from SCSI timeout errors. yoda:~ # tail -f /var/adm/messages Jan 9 11:03:47 yoda.asc.edu scsi: [ID 107833 kern.notice] Requested Block: 239683776 Error Block:

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris better Than Solaris10u6 with requards to ARECA Raid Card

2009-01-13 Thread t. johnson
Just a hunch.. but what kind of drives are you using? Many of the raid card vendors report that consumer class drives are incompatible with their cards because the drives will spend much longer trying to recover from failure than the enterprise class drives will. This causes the card to think

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris better Than Solaris10u6 with requards to ARECA Raid Card

2009-01-13 Thread Charles Wright
Thanks for the reply, I've also had issue with consumer class drives and other raid cards. The drives I have here (all 16 drives) are Seagate® Barracuda® ES enterprise hard drives Model Number ST3500630NS If the problem was with the drive I would expect the same behavior in both solaris and

Re: [zfs-discuss] OpenSolaris better Than Solaris10u6 with requards to ARECA Raid Card

2009-01-13 Thread zfs user
Charles Wright wrote: Under Solaris 10 u6 , No matter how I configured my ARECA 1261ML Raid card I got errors on all drives that result from SCSI timeout errors. [snip litany of errors] I had similar problems on a 1120 card with 2008.05 I upgraded to 2008.11 and the something*.16 sun areca