security-dev
Thread
Date
Earlier messages
Later messages
Messages by Thread
Re: RFR: 8368984: Extra slashes in Cipher transformation leads to NSPE instead of NSAE
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8368984: Extra slashes in Cipher transformation leads to NSPE instead of NSAE [v2]
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8368984: Extra slashes in Cipher transformation leads to NSPE instead of NSAE [v2]
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8368984: Extra slashes in Cipher transformation leads to NSPE instead of NSAE [v4]
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8368984: Extra slashes in Cipher transformation leads to NSPE instead of NSAE [v4]
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8368984: Extra slashes in Cipher transformation leads to NSPE instead of NSAE [v4]
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8368984: Extra slashes in Cipher transformation leads to NSPE instead of NSAE [v3]
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8368984: Extra slashes in Cipher transformation leads to NSPE instead of NSAE [v3]
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8368984: Extra slashes in Cipher transformation leads to NSPE instead of NSAE [v3]
Valerie Peng
Integrated: 8368984: Extra slashes in Cipher transformation leads to NSPE instead of NSAE
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8362268 : NPE thrown from SASL GSSAPI impl when TLS is used with QOP auth-int against Active Directory [v4]
Weibing Xiao
Re: RFR: 8362268 : NPE thrown from SASL GSSAPI impl when TLS is used with QOP auth-int against Active Directory [v4]
Daniel Fuchs
Re: RFR: 8362268 : NPE thrown from SASL GSSAPI impl when TLS is used with QOP auth-int against Active Directory [v4]
Daniel Fuchs
Re: RFR: 8362268 : NPE thrown from SASL GSSAPI impl when TLS is used with QOP auth-int against Active Directory [v4]
Daniel Fuchs
Re: RFR: 8360562: sun/security/tools/keytool/i18n.java add an ability to add comment for failures [v2]
Rajan Halade
Re: RFR: 8360562: sun/security/tools/keytool/i18n.java add an ability to add comment for failures [v2]
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8360562: sun/security/tools/keytool/i18n.java add an ability to add comment for failures [v2]
Rajan Halade
Re: RFR: 8351354: Enhance java -XshowSettings:security:tls to show enabled TLS groups and signature algorithms [v2]
Matthew Donovan
Re: RFR: 8351354: Enhance java -XshowSettings:security:tls to show enabled TLS groups and signature algorithms [v2]
Artur Barashev
New candidate JEP: 527: Post-Quantum Hybrid Key Exchange for TLS 1.3
Mark Reinhold
Re: RFR: 8354469: Keytool exposes the password in plain text when command is piped using | grep [v7]
Weijun Wang
RFR: 8366244: TLS1.3 ChangeCipherSpec message received after the client's Finished message should trigger a connection abort with "unexpected message"
Artur Barashev
Re: RFR: 8366244: TLS1.3 ChangeCipherSpec message received after the client's Finished message should trigger a connection abort with "unexpected message"
Alice Pellegrini
Re: RFR: 8366244: TLS1.3 ChangeCipherSpec message received after the client's Finished message should trigger a connection abort with "unexpected message"
Artur Barashev
Integrated: 8366244: TLS1.3 ChangeCipherSpec message received after the client's Finished message should trigger a connection abort with "unexpected message"
Artur Barashev
Re: RFR: 8366244: TLS1.3 ChangeCipherSpec message received after the client's Finished message should trigger a connection abort with "unexpected message" [v2]
Artur Barashev
Re: RFR: 8366244: TLS1.3 ChangeCipherSpec message received after the client's Finished message should trigger a connection abort with "unexpected message" [v2]
Alice Pellegrini
Re: RFR: 8366244: TLS1.3 ChangeCipherSpec message received after the client's Finished message should trigger a connection abort with "unexpected message" [v2]
Hai-May Chao
Re: RFR: 8354469: Keytool exposes the password in plain text when command is piped using | grep [v10]
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8354469: Keytool exposes the password in plain text when command is piped using | grep [v10]
Sean Mullan
Re: RFR: 8354469: Keytool exposes the password in plain text when command is piped using | grep [v10]
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8354469: Keytool exposes the password in plain text when command is piped using | grep [v10]
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8354469: Keytool exposes the password in plain text when command is piped using | grep [v10]
Naoto Sato
Re: RFR: 8354469: Keytool exposes the password in plain text when command is piped using | grep [v8]
Weijun Wang
RFR: 8368756: Skip sun/security/provider/acvp/Launcher.java when ACVP-Server artifact isn't found
Francesco Andreuzzi
Re: RFR: 8368756: Skip sun/security/provider/acvp/Launcher.java when ACVP-Server artifact isn't found
Francesco Andreuzzi
Withdrawn: 8368756: Skip sun/security/provider/acvp/Launcher.java when ACVP-Server artifact isn't found
Francesco Andreuzzi
Integrated: 8357691: File blocked.certs contains bad content when boot jdk 25 is used, sun/security/lib/CheckBlockedCerts.java failing
Matthias Baesken
Re: RFR: 8357691: File blocked.certs contains bad content when boot jdk 25 is used, sun/security/lib/CheckBlockedCerts.java failing
Ioi Lam
Re: RFR: 8357691: File blocked.certs contains bad content when boot jdk 25 is used, sun/security/lib/CheckBlockedCerts.java failing
Matthias Baesken
RFR: 8368520: TLS 1.3 KeyUpdate fails with SunPKCS11 provider
Daniel Jeliński
Integrated: 8368520: TLS 1.3 KeyUpdate fails with SunPKCS11 provider
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368520: TLS 1.3 KeyUpdate fails with SunPKCS11 provider [v2]
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368520: TLS 1.3 KeyUpdate fails with SunPKCS11 provider [v2]
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8368520: TLS 1.3 KeyUpdate fails with SunPKCS11 provider [v2]
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368520: TLS 1.3 KeyUpdate fails with SunPKCS11 provider [v2]
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8368520: TLS 1.3 KeyUpdate fails with SunPKCS11 provider [v2]
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368520: TLS 1.3 KeyUpdate fails with SunPKCS11 provider
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8368520: TLS 1.3 KeyUpdate fails with SunPKCS11 provider
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8368520: TLS 1.3 KeyUpdate fails with SunPKCS11 provider [v2]
Daniel Jeliński
Integrated: 8360463: Ambiguity in Cipher.getInstance() specification between NoSuchAlgorithmException and NoSuchPaddingException
Valerie Peng
RFR: 8368694: PKCS11-NSS generic keys generated by DH have leading zeroes stripped
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368694: PKCS11-NSS generic keys generated by DH have leading zeroes stripped
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8368694: PKCS11-NSS generic keys generated by DH have leading zeroes stripped [v2]
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368694: PKCS11-NSS generic keys generated by DH have leading zeroes stripped [v2]
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368694: PKCS11-NSS generic keys generated by DH have leading zeroes stripped [v2]
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8368694: PKCS11-NSS generic keys generated by DH have leading zeroes stripped [v2]
Daniel Jeliński
Integrated: 8368694: PKCS11-NSS generic keys generated by DH have leading zeroes stripped
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8354469: Keytool exposes the password in plain text when command is piped using | grep [v6]
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8354469: Keytool exposes the password in plain text when command is piped using | grep [v6]
Sean Mullan
Re: RFR: 8354469: Keytool exposes the password in plain text when command is piped using | grep [v6]
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8354469: Keytool exposes the password in plain text when command is piped using | grep [v6]
Sean Mullan
RFR: 8368677: acvp test should throw SkippedException when no ACVP-Server available
SendaoYan
Re: RFR: 8368677: acvp test should throw SkippedException when no ACVP-Server available [v2]
SendaoYan
Re: RFR: 8368677: acvp test should throw SkippedException when no ACVP-Server available [v2]
Aleksey Shipilev
Re: RFR: 8368677: acvp test should throw SkippedException when no ACVP-Server available [v2]
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8368677: acvp test should throw SkippedException when no ACVP-Server available [v2]
SendaoYan
Re: RFR: 8368677: acvp test should throw SkippedException when no ACVP-Server available [v2]
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8368677: acvp test should throw SkippedException when no ACVP-Server available
Aleksey Shipilev
Re: RFR: 8368677: acvp test should throw SkippedException when no ACVP-Server available
SendaoYan
Re: RFR: 8368677: acvp test should throw SkippedException when no ACVP-Server available
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8368677: acvp test should throw SkippedException when no ACVP-Server available
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8368677: acvp test should throw SkippedException when no ACVP-Server available
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8368677: acvp test should throw SkippedException when no ACVP-Server available
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8368677: acvp test should throw SkippedException when no ACVP-Server available [v2]
SendaoYan
Integrated: 8368677: acvp test should throw SkippedException when no ACVP-Server available
SendaoYan
Re: RFR: 8368677: acvp test should throw SkippedException when no ACVP-Server available
Aleksey Shipilev
Re: RFR: 8360498: [TEST_BUG] Some Mixing test continue to fail [v16]
Khalid Boulanouare
Re: RFR: 8360498: [TEST_BUG] Some Mixing test continue to fail [v16]
Alan Bateman
Re: RFR: 8360498: [TEST_BUG] Some Mixing test continue to fail [v16]
Khalid Boulanouare
Re: RFR: 8360498: [TEST_BUG] Some Mixing test continue to fail [v15]
Khalid Boulanouare
Re: RFR: 8044609: javax.net.debug options not working and documented as expected [v22]
Sean Coffey
Integrated: 8360979: Remove use of Thread.stop in krb5/auto/KDC.java
Mikhail Yankelevich
RFR: 8368514: TLS stateless session ticket decryption fails on some providers
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368514: TLS stateless session ticket decryption fails on some providers
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368514: TLS stateless session ticket decryption fails on some providers [v2]
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368514: TLS stateless session ticket decryption fails on some providers [v2]
Artur Barashev
Re: RFR: 8368514: TLS stateless session ticket decryption fails on some providers [v2]
Artur Barashev
Re: RFR: 8368514: TLS stateless session ticket decryption fails on some providers [v2]
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368514: TLS stateless session ticket decryption fails on some providers [v2]
Valerie Peng
Integrated: 8368514: TLS stateless session ticket decryption fails on some providers
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368514: TLS stateless session ticket decryption fails on some providers
Artur Barashev
Re: RFR: 8368514: TLS stateless session ticket decryption fails on some providers
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8368514: TLS stateless session ticket decryption fails on some providers
Artur Barashev
Re: RFR: 8368514: TLS stateless session ticket decryption fails on some providers
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368514: TLS stateless session ticket decryption fails on some providers
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368514: TLS stateless session ticket decryption fails on some providers
Valerie Peng
RFR: 8366454: TLS1.3 server fails with bad_record_mac when receiving encrypted records with empty body
Alice Pellegrini
Re: RFR: 8366454: TLS1.3 server fails with bad_record_mac when receiving encrypted records with empty body [v2]
Alice Pellegrini
Re: RFR: 8366454: TLS1.3 server fails with bad_record_mac when receiving encrypted records with empty body [v2]
duke
Re: RFR: 8366454: TLS1.3 server fails with bad_record_mac when receiving encrypted records with empty body [v2]
Daniel Jeliński
Integrated: 8366454: TLS1.3 server fails with bad_record_mac when receiving encrypted records with empty body
Alice Pellegrini
Re: RFR: 8366454: TLS1.3 server fails with bad_record_mac when receiving encrypted records with empty body
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8366454: TLS1.3 server fails with bad_record_mac when receiving encrypted records with empty body
Alice Pellegrini
Integrated: 8343395: SSLLogger doesn't work for formatted messages
Sean Coffey
Re: RFR: 8360979: Remove use of Thread.stop in krb5/auto/KDC.java [v2]
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8360979: Remove use of Thread.stop in krb5/auto/KDC.java [v2]
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8360979: Remove use of Thread.stop in krb5/auto/KDC.java [v2]
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8360979: Remove use of Thread.stop in krb5/auto/KDC.java [v2]
Mikhail Yankelevich
RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop
Alan Bateman
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop [v3]
Alan Bateman
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop [v3]
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop
Alan Bateman
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop [v2]
Alan Bateman
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop [v2]
Sergey Bylokhov
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop [v2]
Iris Clark
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop [v2]
Pavel Rappo
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop
Jaikiran Pai
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop [v3]
Alan Bateman
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop [v3]
Jaikiran Pai
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop [v3]
Lance Andersen
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop [v3]
Alan Bateman
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop [v3]
Viktor Klang
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop
Roger Riggs
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop [v2]
Alan Bateman
Integrated: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop
Alan Bateman
Re: RFR: 8368226: Remove Thread.stop
Viktor Klang
Re: RFR: 8349910: Implement JEP 517: HTTP/3 for the HTTP Client API [v19]
Daniel Fuchs
Re: RFR: 8349910: Implement JEP 517: HTTP/3 for the HTTP Client API [v19]
Jaikiran Pai
Re: RFR: 8349910: Implement JEP 517: HTTP/3 for the HTTP Client API [v19]
Aleksei Efimov
Re: RFR: 8349910: Implement JEP 517: HTTP/3 for the HTTP Client API [v19]
Daniel Jeliński
RFR: 8367583: sun/security/util/AlgorithmConstraints/InvalidCryptoDisabledAlgos.java fails after JDK-8244336
Jaikiran Pai
Re: RFR: 8367583: sun/security/util/AlgorithmConstraints/InvalidCryptoDisabledAlgos.java fails after JDK-8244336
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8367583: sun/security/util/AlgorithmConstraints/InvalidCryptoDisabledAlgos.java fails after JDK-8244336
Jaikiran Pai
Re: RFR: 8367583: sun/security/util/AlgorithmConstraints/InvalidCryptoDisabledAlgos.java fails after JDK-8244336
Jaikiran Pai
Integrated: 8367583: sun/security/util/AlgorithmConstraints/InvalidCryptoDisabledAlgos.java fails after JDK-8244336
Jaikiran Pai
Re: RFR: 8365732: RISC-V: implement AES CTR intrinsics [v9]
Anjian Wen
Re: RFR: 8365732: RISC-V: implement AES CTR intrinsics [v7]
Anjian Wen
Re: RFR: 8343395: SSLLogger doesn't work for formatted messages [v7]
Sean Coffey
Re: RFR: 8343395: SSLLogger doesn't work for formatted messages [v7]
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8343395: SSLLogger doesn't work for formatted messages [v7]
Sean Coffey
Re: RFR: 8343395: SSLLogger doesn't work for formatted messages [v6]
Sean Coffey
RFR: 8368073: PKCS11 HKDF can't use byte array IKM in FIPS mode
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368073: PKCS11 HKDF can't use byte array IKM in FIPS mode
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8368073: PKCS11 HKDF can't use byte array IKM in FIPS mode
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8368073: PKCS11 HKDF can't use byte array IKM in FIPS mode [v2]
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368073: PKCS11 HKDF can't use byte array IKM in FIPS mode
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8368073: PKCS11 HKDF can't use byte array IKM in FIPS mode [v2]
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368073: PKCS11 HKDF can't use byte array IKM in FIPS mode [v2]
Valerie Peng
Integrated: 8368073: PKCS11 HKDF can't use byte array IKM in FIPS mode
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368073: PKCS11 HKDF can't use byte array IKM in FIPS mode [v2]
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368073: PKCS11 HKDF can't use byte array IKM in FIPS mode [v2]
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8368073: PKCS11 HKDF can't use byte array IKM in FIPS mode [v2]
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368073: PKCS11 HKDF can't use byte array IKM in FIPS mode [v2]
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8368073: PKCS11 HKDF can't use byte array IKM in FIPS mode
Valerie Peng
RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip
SendaoYan
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip [v3]
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip [v3]
Rajan Halade
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip [v3]
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip [v2]
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip [v2]
Matthew Donovan
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip [v2]
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip
Matthew Donovan
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip [v2]
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip [v2]
Matthew Donovan
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip [v4]
Rajan Halade
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip [v4]
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip [v4]
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip [v4]
Rajan Halade
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip [v4]
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip [v5]
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip [v6]
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip [v6]
Rajan Halade
Integrated: 8367994: test/jdk/sun/security/pkcs11/Signature/ tests pass when they should skip
Mikhail Yankelevich
Re: RFR: 8343395: SSLLogger doesn't work for formatted messages [v5]
Sean Coffey
Re: RFR: 8343395: SSLLogger doesn't work for formatted messages [v5]
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8343395: SSLLogger doesn't work for formatted messages [v5]
Sean Coffey
Re: RFR: 8360463: Ambiguity in Cipher.getInstance() specification between NoSuchAlgorithmException and NoSuchPaddingException [v8]
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8360463: Ambiguity in Cipher.getInstance() specification between NoSuchAlgorithmException and NoSuchPaddingException [v8]
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8360463: Ambiguity in Cipher.getInstance() specification between NoSuchAlgorithmException and NoSuchPaddingException [v8]
Sean Mullan
Re: RFR: 8360463: Ambiguity in Cipher.getInstance() specification between NoSuchAlgorithmException and NoSuchPaddingException [v8]
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8360463: Ambiguity in Cipher.getInstance() specification between NoSuchAlgorithmException and NoSuchPaddingException [v8]
Sean Mullan
Re: RFR: 8360463: Ambiguity in Cipher.getInstance() specification between NoSuchAlgorithmException and NoSuchPaddingException [v8]
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8360463: Ambiguity in Cipher.getInstance() specification between NoSuchAlgorithmException and NoSuchPaddingException [v8]
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8360463: Ambiguity in Cipher.getInstance() specification between NoSuchAlgorithmException and NoSuchPaddingException [v8]
Sean Mullan
Re: RFR: 8360463: Ambiguity in Cipher.getInstance() specification between NoSuchAlgorithmException and NoSuchPaddingException [v8]
Valerie Peng
Re: RFR: 8360463: Ambiguity in Cipher.getInstance() specification between NoSuchAlgorithmException and NoSuchPaddingException [v8]
Weijun Wang
Re: RFR: 8360463: Ambiguity in Cipher.getInstance() specification between NoSuchAlgorithmException and NoSuchPaddingException [v8]
Sean Mullan
Re: RFR: 8354469: Keytool exposes the password in plain text when command is piped using | grep [v2]
Weijun Wang
Integrated: 8361711: Add library name configurability to PKCS11Test.java
Thomas Fitzsimmons
Re: RFR: 8349910: Implement JEP 517: HTTP/3 for the HTTP Client API [v18]
Daniel Fuchs
Re: RFR: 8349910: Implement JEP 517: HTTP/3 for the HTTP Client API [v18]
Daniel Jeliński
Re: RFR: 8349910: Implement JEP 517: HTTP/3 for the HTTP Client API [v18]
Jaikiran Pai
Re: RFR: 8349910: Implement JEP 517: HTTP/3 for the HTTP Client API [v18]
Aleksei Efimov
Re: RFR: 8349910: Implement JEP 517: HTTP/3 for the HTTP Client API [v18]
Michael McMahon
Earlier messages
Later messages