Hi Mark,

Thanks for your review. Please see my inline comments.

----- ??? -----
?: Mark Martin <storycrafter at gmail.com>
??: ???, 2009 ? 6? 18?, ??11:57
??: Re: [sfwnv-discuss] Code review request for jedit after PSARC
???: "rusong.zheng" <Rusong.Zheng at Sun.COM>
??: sfwnv-discuss at opensolaris.org

> rusong.zheng wrote:
> >Hi,
> >
> >Per ARC's request, changes to webrev are :
> >
> >/usr/share/jedit/4.3pre16/      ==>/usr/share/jedit/
> >
> >sunman/jedit.1                       ==>jedit.1          sunman is 
> removed>build.xml.patch                      
> ==>patches/build.xml.patch>build.properties.patch           
> ==>patches/build.properties.patch>jedit.patch                       
>       ==>patches/jedit.patch
> >
> >directory classes is removed for that contents of it are 
> duplicated (class files and API docs,  class files already be 
> contained in jedit.jar, APIs doc already in doc/API/)
> >jedit is removed from /usr/share/jedit/jedit and moved to 
> /usr/bin/jedit>
> >Makefile.sfw, install_sfw and prototype_com are changed accordingly.
> >
> >Besides that, METADATA file has been changed to meet the new 
> requirement. All the others are the same as the last round of review.
> >
> >Please help review them.
> >
> >Webrev is at:
> >http://cr.opensolaris.org/~rszheng/jedit/
> >
> >PSARC case url is:
> >http://arc.opensolaris.org/caselog/PSARC/2009/357/
> I'm confused about the script "jedit", and I'll admit it's because 
> this is the first java->sfw project I've code reviewed. That, and 
> my Make is probably a little rusty.
> 
> It occurs to me that the patch creates a file jedit.sh.  If that is 
> true:a) Where is "jedit" that's been referenced as /usr/bin/jedit
> b) Is that the appropriate name?
> 
> 
Yes, jedit here is a script to run "java -jar jedit.jar". 
for a), the script did not exist firstly. I wrote a script and make a diff to 
generate the patch, and original script I wrote is removed. When build is 
finished, the script will be generated and installed to /usr/bin/. So 
/usr/bin/jedit is itself a script and don't refer to other file.

for b), I think it is easy to use: user can just type "jedit"  commandline to 
run jedit.jar. 

Thanks,
Rusong

Reply via email to