In a message dated 6/15/00 11:13:49 PM EST, [email protected] writes:

<< Not trying to attack you Roger, just looking for some data! I realize you 
were
 looking for nitric acid, to explain the low pH but I wonder if the 
 reference I have,
 that indicates nitrites (which we all know are killers for humans) are 
 likely!

Fred: I'll ask the chemist who has my sample about the likelihood that 
nitrites are present and the possibility to analyze for it. Happy?

 
 Apparently the EPA limit in potable water is 45PPM for nitrates but zero 
 for nitrites.
 
 I do not think there is any dispute that the HVAC arc process produces 
nitrogen
 compounds

Fred: Until we see actual data for properly documented process conditions 
this point is very much is dispute.

and sintered elemental silver particles, not the higher bio-available
 silver ions.

Fred: I have yet to see any edidence to support your "higher bio-available 
silver ion" claim. You're simply repeating statements made by you and some 
others on this list. Show me the data to support this claim!

Granted, you may have a silver colloid with charged particles  but an
 electrostatic charge will not have the chemical reactivity of an ionic 
charge.

Fred: Again. Show me the data that supports such a statement.
 
 As for your high "killing" power, silver nitrate has a long and successful 
 history of efficient medical applications, albeit serious side effects like 
 manufactured drugs!

Fred: You're implying that I have made silver nitrate. First, you claim that 
I've made nothing but sintered neutral silver particles which are useless to 
kill germs (and you have never provided any hard data to support this 
contention). Now you're telling us that if I did make silver ions they were 
in the form of silver nitrate which is dangerous to ingest. Well, I'll say it 
again. There is no nitrate in my product, and I have the chemical analysis 
from a reputable lab to back up my claim. Which lab are you using to back up 
your claims?

 It is evidence of the efficiency of silver ions (soluble salts disassociate 
 to ions and anions, cations or whatever). I and others who have serious 
questions about the HVAC process, question what you are serving your friends 
, not how potent  it is! 

Fred: Give me one iote of HARD DATA to back up your so-called concern.
 
The posts from 'OLE" Bob you may note (it was his sample I have) show that 
 he is the most unbiased here, having expended money to build and experiment 
with 
 HVAC,  as a means to produce a better product and assist others, not to 
market 
 anything! His recent shielded electrode test (like my prior idea of an inert 
 atmosphere) and the submerged electrode test (with their minor pH drops), 
clearly gave evidence that the big pH dip in an open arc is from nitrogen 
products! 

Fred: To paraphrase Ivan, smelling and tasting things does not constitute 
HARD EVIDENCE. Suspicion yes, evidence no. What's good for the goose (Ivan 
used this statement to criticise my TENTATIVE conclusion) is also good for 
the gander (i.e., I can certainly use this same criticism with regard to your 
conclusions) 

What they are is still up  for grabs, in my mind and I hope yours, since your 
nitrate test was negative!
 
Biased I, sell what I consider the best LVDC unit (also maybe the most 
 costly) but  spend a great deal of time in research and web design time to 
help others with my medical findings - you have to search on my site to find 
my product! I have also  disclosed to you and the other list members full 
details on exactly how I make my unit. With  over 40 years in the design and 
manufacture of custom HVAC and DC research tools I would  love to utilize 
that experience but for a 2 volt DC process I still wonder what all  the 
hoopla is about HVAC. (Fast yes, known product no!)
 
Fred: No doubt you have very strong opinions. Please support your opinions 
with HARD DATA..

 I will find out and publish my findings with or without your sample and pay 
 for some lab tests if needed! What if the rapidly growing HVAC industry is 
screwing with our bodies like the drug companies, simply because they will 
not validate what they  are making!

Fred: You sound a little hysterical here. Are you on some sort of campaign to 
rub out HVAC CS in the marketplace for personal reasons?
 
The alternative health field is an attempt to escape fatal research with 
 untested drugs - if you can not tell me what you made, I don't want it!

Fred: OK. OK. Calm down.
 
 Your thought that ions of silver do not exist, only elemental silver, is so 
 far from the main stream

Fred: It wasn't so long ago that the "main stream" thought that Newtonian 
physics was exact at any velocity. Today, we know that isn't true. But again, 
I must ask you to provide HARD DATA to support your so-called mainstream view.

eviI wonder what you think about a solute such as silver nitrate. Is there 
disassociation or will the silver just lose its bond, to drop out as 
elemental silver?
 
 If you have reasons why elemental silver is not a catalyst for H2O2, or why 
 Cl will not complex with silver ions or that silver chloride is not 
insoluble in water, 
 I would love to review it! We hashed these simple "do at home test" ideas 
over pretty well before on this list and had no dissension other then that 
they are qualitative and  not quantitative.

Fred: The fact that there was no dissension hardly constitutes proof that 
these tests are accurate. When you're dealing with catalytic reactions 
(dissociation of H2O2. for example) you have to be very careful about making 
conclusions without exhaustive testing using, for example, samples of known 
morphology to test for agreement with your proposed methodology. Until you've 
done that, you have NO PROOF that your conclusions are correct. 

My goal, as with others, was to make some simple tests the home hacker 
could use to validate their "wonder what I made" product questions.

Fred: That's a noble goal, but there is no evidence that the method has any 
predictive value especially with regard to the efficacy (germ killing power) 
of the CS produced.
 
 For my purpose of detecting elemental silver or silver ions, they work well 
 and validate my desire to produce no elemental silver! I do believe your 
body stores up elemental metals, as with any metallic toxin, and is the 
primary cause of argyria, if not death.

Fred: Well I'm not dead yet, but I will admit to having some problems passing 
through those darn metal detectors at the airport!

There have been many tests to validate the discharge of up to 98% of silver 
ions 
 in 24 hours and thus the near improbability of having argyria or a fatality 
with ionic 
 forms.

Fred: Good for you.
 
 Love to do a bio-activity test - still waiting for a suggested subject, but 
 the point , as I mention above is not killing power but safety AND killing 
power. There are  lot better bactericides and viricides but few with the 
safety we look for in Cs! Maybe what you have is structured water with a 
silver ion signature and then it would be  effective even if diluted 
100,000,000 to 1 (or even 10 to the 120th  power).
         See     http://www.digibio.com/cgi-bin/node.pl?lg=us&nd=n4_1

Fred: Yes. I think you should be much more liberal with 'maybe' throughout 
your writing
 
 <snip>(talk about structured water!!)
 When human polymorphonuclear basophils, a type of white blood cell with
    antibodies of the immunoglobulin E (IgE) type on its surface, are exposed 
to
    anti-IgE antibodies, they release histamine from their intracellular 
 granules and
    change their staining properties. The latter can be demonstrated at 
 dilutions of
    anti-IgE that range from 1 X 10^2 to 1 x 10^120; over that range, there 
are
    successive peaks of degranulation front 40 to 60% of the basophils, 
 despite the
    calculated absence of any anti-IgE molecules at the highest dilutions. 
Since
    dilutions need to be accompanied by vigorous shaking for the effects to be
    observed, transmission of the biological information could be related to 
the
    molecular organization of water.
 </snip>
 
 My problem with using his theory is "how do you ensure the signature is a 
 good one
 and not a bad one of say nitrite"!

Fred: I'm wondering what you are going to come up with next when my sample 
comes back with, "no detectible nitrite". One thing is for sure, you're 
creative enough to invent SOMETHING new to keep people on this list from 
trying HVAC CS which appears to be about as dangerous (and as tasty, I might 
add) as drinking pure water.

Roger
 
 


--
The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver.

To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: 
[email protected]  -or-  [email protected]
with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line.

To post, address your message to: [email protected]
Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html
List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>