Dear Mike,
                I do not propose to be a pontiff, nor declare to hold wisdom
to any marked degree....but I will offer some comments with a view toward
encouraging harmony and civility among our membership.
                First, it is unfortunate that two such fine intellects as
Frank and Stephen have clashed in such a strident manner......I believe we
are all the poorer for the circumstance.  First, because each seems to have
lost sight of the responsibility they carry----if only as a result of the
objective force each can bring to bear in questions of moment.....affecting
the list membership.
                I do not believe you should be called upon to execute an
"Act Of Solomon".......but do understand that List Survival as a harmonious
entity of information exchange-----is, indeed, your most challenging
responsibility.
                    I have no wisdom to submit....expecially none entailing
directions of conduct or judgement-----FOR YOU.
                However, I do offer some for Frank and Stephen.  The measure
of a person is, many times, determined by their ability to distance
themselves from themselves.......especially in matters of consequence to
others.   I believe each of us has an intrinsic responsiblity to the
sentient community-----in exact measure of our talents, capability and
knowledge.  When we use our advantages of formal education, specific
knowledge (objective or otherwise), physical superiority.....or intellectual
power....... for  non-altruistic purposes, we fail both ourselves and
greater destiny.  I know such may look like power, feel like power.....but
may not be power;  especially if power is, truly, the ability to achieve
purpose.
            I do not believe either Frank or  Stephen consciously endeavored
to be mean-spirited  and do believe their differences  were directed toward
EACH OTHER and were not designed  to influence the non-aligned membership.
Sadly, I am equally convinced that both allowed personal emotion to gain
supremacy----if only for a moment.
            Both of you display the evidences of leadership capacity in
numerous ways---including fine, quick minds, superior educational
background, cryptic language protocols, and elevated objective training.
Neither needs either an audience or a cult of followers to achieve high
marks in this society.
            My appeal to you gentlemen is to truly, live up to your
knowledge of life and BE leaders.  Each of you may have engendered or
received circumstances you feel qualify your responses to each other.  That
condition non-withstanding, I encourage you both, not only to resist the
temptation to "be most correct";  but to display the personal maturity I
feel each to possess-----and bury the hatchet-----BUT NOT IN EACH OTHER.
            It either of you departs under a cloud of imagined mistreatment,
I believe that ALL of us involved....including yourselves----will be greatly
impoverished.
            At my stage in life I do feel entitled to admonish over
zealousness----from  whatever cause-----and to add my admiration of both of
your talents, plus my gratitude that our society does, still, possess such
enterprising souls-----as you both exhibit.
                Sincerely,  Brooks.
----- Original Message -----
From: "M. G. Devour" <[email protected]>
To: <[email protected]>
Sent: Tuesday, September 18, 2001 1:25 PM
Subject: CS>Criticism


> Stephen Quinto wrote:
> > But much information has become available through such a medium as
> > this 'silver list'.  It is a shame that some of the discourse has --
> > which may have unfortunately descended into confrontation -- been
> > suppressed in defense of 'list ettiquette' or that the list has been
> > deprived of any participant [which it also has been] in such defense.
> > I have personally been enlightened by such discourse, and am
> > appreciative of what I've learned here.
>
> Some time ago, a small group of folks searching out information on
> Colloidal Silver were offered a sheltered place to gather and trade
> ideas and encouragement.
>
> Thus the silver list was established by the kindness of Gary Hawkins.
>
> Most were intent on making their own CS, building their own generators,
> finding out which commercial products were of consistent quality and
> reasonably priced, and sharing the positive health outcomes they had
> achieved.
>
> There were occasional problems, of course, as in any human endeavor,
> and adjustments were made as personalities and seasons changed. But,
> overall, we earned high marks for being a *friendly* and *helpful*
> group.
>
> People with proprietary interests were welcome on a non-commercial
> basis, and the handful that participated did so in a generous and
> congenial fashion. There are, in fact, still vendors active on this
> list that, unless you knew them well, you'd never realize had any
> business interest at all.
>
> In recent months we have encountered a handful of individuals with
> commercial interests who have shown less regard for consideration and
> politeness than is consistent with the old model of "friendly, helpful,
> congenial." In the course of their debates, we have been subjected to
> bickering, personal attacks, and displays of ego.
>
> The late, lamented Stuart, whom Stephen is referring to above, arrived
> on the list in a verbal dung-heap of rude and thoughtless denunciations
> of every person who posted a message he felt was off topic, complete
> with name calling and insults.
>
> The remaining months of Stuart's participation on the list, though
> valuable at times, were punctuated by further breaches of "list
> etiquette" that required correction. He seemed to believe that the
> value of his participation was of a higher precedence than my
> expectations of civility and politeness.
>
> In addition, we have enjoyed, or endured, depending on your point of
> view, the presence of Frank Key, who, like Stephen and Stuart, brought
> with him considerable knowledge and the results of some serious
> research into Colloidal Silver. His worst failing has been his
> inability to let diplomacy temper the certainty of his claims. He has
> also, at times, ignored "list etiquette" in favor of retaliation in
> kind for insults and abuse that have been directed his way.
>
> It appears that Frank and Stephen and Stuart were and are
> constitutionally incapable of getting along with each other without
> subjecting the rest of us to debates that *inevitably* involve a measure
> of personal conflict that is unpleasant and unnecessary.
>
> These are the principle characters, and this the central drama of the
> moment.
>
> In contrast, one fellow, Ole' Bob, has spared us the brunt of his
> curmudgeonly opinions and the inevitable disagreements from others, by
> the frequent expedient of asking "Contact me off-list!" Lord knows what
> dangerous heresies Bob is contaminating impressionable new members with
> in such clandestine meetings! <grin>
>
> That strategy has worked in Bob's case, though at the price of
> depriving our many lurkers of basic tutorial information that used to
> be far more common here, back when we had a consensus that any CS was
> better than no CS and that simple was adequate to start with.
>
> So, on the one hand, I'm being criticized for "suppressing" the freedom
> of "scientific inquiry."
>
> On the other hand, I know the *inevitable* results of letting all hell
> break loose and arguments go on interminably, wherein we lose members
> in disgust (and in quantity), while even the better behaved technical
> discussions have a strong tendency to dominate the list and drive new
> members away empty handed.
>
> On the gripping hand, the list benefits from the expertise of all
> members who contribute, and these individuals are certainly a valued
> part of our "brain trust."
>
> So there's a price to pay, no matter which way we go.
>
> I can't resolve the conflict, folks!
>
> Stephen,
>
> In addition to my own impressions, I recently received a heartfelt
> testimonial to the value of your participation and the quality of your
> contribution to the cause of promoting colloidal silver from a list
> member I respect. So please do not believe that I underestimate your
> worth, sir.
>
> But if I am to change the basic principles by which I moderate the
> silver list, I must have ample reason to believe that the results will
> be better for the membership as a whole.
>
> I am reluctant to place "list etiquette" in an inferior place to
> "scientific inquiry" when the latter 1) never resolves the key issues
> of debate, and 2) has contributed to poisoning the atmosphere due to
> the personal foibles of those principally involved.
>
> I have allowed the technical discussions, and the difficulties that go
> with them, in the hope that we will learn from them. I have bent over
> backward to achieve an acceptable balance between tech talk, aid to new
> people, and general happy chit-chat.
>
> I am afraid that I've failed, and that the rigid postures of a few
> individuals may indeed mean that such a balance is impossible at this
> time. Sadly, I don't see any way to resolve the personality conflicts.
>
> My heart and my mind both tell me that even *ONE* person being helped
> by reclaiming the helpful, friendly, generous nature of our group
> outweighs the value to be gained from continued bickering amongst a
> handful of individuals, however gifted, and that even *ONE* new person
> alienated by contentious disagreements over arcana is too many.
>
> You've asked that this debate take place in full view of the list and
> have taken steps to bring that about. I accede to your request. Here we
> are. I'd like to know what you and the rest of the members think I
> should do.
>
> Be well,
>
> Mike Devour
> silver-list owner
>
> [Mike Devour, Citizen, Patriot, Libertarian]
> [[email protected]                        ]
> [Speaking only for myself...               ]
>
>
> --
> The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver.
>
> To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to:
> [email protected]  -or-  [email protected]
> with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line.
>
> To post, address your message to: [email protected]
> Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html
> List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>
>