Mike,

I think it was necessary to raise the dilemma to the entire list because
there is an underlying issue that has remained in the shadows. Of course
your considerations as owner and moderator are often different than those
who subscribe to the list.... that adds another dimension.  It might be
argued that social comfort is a greater goal, a nobler sacrifice, than
individual freedom [of expression].  But I am not going to raise it here.
I've grown more exigent over the years, not less.  I've been known to open
my mouth -- at my own ultimate expense -- because I felt the principle at
issue was too important to compromise.  The underlying issue is Stuart.....

Yeah, Stuart barged in on this list like a dump truck, crushing growth that
had been planted in a garden of relative propriety. He was gross and
insensitive in his first entrance upon this new [for him] list.  I remember
it quite well.  In fact I too was taken aback at his impatience with anyone,
his outrageous wunderkind style and zealous pursuit of unimportant matters.
But he did approach the quandries of CS with an always fresh point of view,
perspicacious rather than linear and was openhearted even to criticism.  He
just could not keep his argumentative disposition under sufficient control,
especially when frustrated by Frank.  So you, too, Mike, were offended --
and then exercised ....to the point of acting in anger and extinguishing
him. I was rankled by your 'execution' of him then; I still am.

Perhaps more should have been made of it at the time, or less, depending on
your perspective.  But I have also learned much of enduring value here
....even from Frank.  Although I don't always have the luxury of time to
participate, I have not wanted to miss any items of interest either.
Besides, there are some wonderful and generous people here who share their
knowledge and experience without hesitation.

This is not meant to change things.  None of us can redress the past. But we
must speak up when it becomes necessary.

Some days ago I saw a graph developed from data on his site in which
Mesosilver towers over all the poor also-rans in a  determination of
bactericidal efficacy, based only on a theoretical presumption.  So I
decided to obtain a sample, test it and publish the results -- no matter
[where the chips fell].  That's what we did. And we stand by the work -- in
spite of threats of legal action by Frank, we are not going to pull the
content....!

Our laboratory is proud of its achievements and passionately defends its
integrity from within as well as without.   We are open to challenge for
whatever we do; AND it remains our responsibility of everyone to speak up
when they see wrong.....

Stephen


--
The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver.

To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: 
[email protected]  -or-  [email protected]
with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line.

To post, address your message to: [email protected]
Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html
List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>