Marshall,
I appreciate your tip about letting the solution dry on a towel, in
order to see if the color remains. It's a very sensible way of
ascertaining the use of food coloring. (Has anyone found food coloring
in a CS product?) But on the other hand I want to point out that you are
wrong about what you refer to as the impossibility of CS being orange.

Just yesterday I prepared a batch of concentrated, LV CS, I believe to
be something over 200ppm. During the brewing it turns yellow and goes
progressively to orange, amber, dark amber and finally is too dark to
see transmitted light (depending on the thickness of the container). In
the two liter Erlenmeyer flask I use the CS ends up being opaque, gray
green. When I dilute it down it can be any of the aforementioned colors,
depending on the amount of water used.

I guess I thought that the naysayers had been silenced for the time
being, as to the possibility of making concentrated CS. Somebody just
got on the other day and said he had tested some CS and found it to be
about 98ppm. (But my brain being increasingly feeble I cannot recall who
that was. Sorry.) I would imagine that darker orange has nothing
necessarily to do with increasingly large particles, simply many
additional particles. On my generator I reverse polarity every minute,
with the understanding this helps keep the particle size down.

Meanwhile, when Laura tells about the particular bottle of CS she
purchased (as she's indicated she will do) we can hope to be a little
more specific. As to what you say is optimum, 10ppm or whatever, I think
you (and incidentally Ted) should understand that diluted, concentrated
CS is still, very often, highly beneficial as well as being economical.
It may not be what you and a lot of other people here do, but it's still
a reality. And incidentally, with his equations in physical chemistry I
think Roger has helped put to rest the misguided notion that protein is
necessary in keeping concentrated CS in suspension.

Thanks for your patience with my sometimes circuitous explanations. As a
scientist I am still a fledgling.
Yours in CS,
Reid
P.S. When making CS I find the yellow more appealing when I think of it
as brewing 'beer yellow.'

Reid said:
Laura,
....There have been lots of rumors of food coloring here lately, and my
guess is that this has to do with is-information from people/ companies
who for whatever reason are deliberately doing their best to discredit
colloidal silver....

Then Marshall said:
That is not the case at all.  If it is food coloring without any CS then
that would be the big discredit risk.  Pure CS is not dark orange, at
any ppm.  One can get a light orange, but if they do, that means that
the particles are larger than most of us consider optimum.

The color (if any) of CS disappears if you put it on a towel and let it
dry.  CS will always dry colorless or black.  If you put it on a towel
and it dries orange it has to have food coloring or some other pigment
in it.

If there is any chance that these do not contain what they claim, then
the people on this list are correct in cautioning the use of the
product.  After all a person's life or health may be in danger.  And
worse of all, if we say that it is good stuff, and it is nothing more
than food coloring, then when people try it and it does nothing we have
lost possibly the only oportunity to convince the person that CS does
really work.

I believe these preparations contain fairly large silver particles, kept
in suspension by some type of protein, possibly gelatin, with additional
coloring added.  If anyone is able to run any tests to disprove this, I
would be happy to admit I am wrong.

Most of these warnings are coming from people who make and use their own
CS.

Marshall



--
The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver.

To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: 
[email protected]  -or-  [email protected]
with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line.

To post, address your message to: [email protected]
Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html
List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>