url: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/m63298.html
CS>Re: Measuring very high ppms
From: Jrowland
Date: Thu, 9 Oct 2003 16:15:57

  > "Well, maybe it is, and maybe it ain't...
  > "Say, Tom, let me whitewash a little."
  > http://www-2.cs.cmu.edu/People/rgs/sawyr-II.html

  > jr

  jr,

  I get  the  impression you are trying to say  something.  Perhaps it
  involves Bob Lee's Faraday equations, maybe it's something else.

  But since you seem to be stuck on this issue, maybe I can help.

  As you  know,  when  Herx  posted the  Excel  version  of  Bob Lee's
  calculations on  the Yahoo silver group, I was one of  the  first to
  point out this represented a "not greater" number, since it  did not
  include the loss due to oxide formation at the electrodes.

  There has  never been any question about this. It is  obvious. Bruce
  Stenulson pointed it out as early as Apr, 1998

    http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/m1664.html

  I don't  know  if  you are trying to insinuate  that  I  claimed the
  Faraday equations  would  predict the actual  ppm  of  the resulting
  solution.

  I always  use  ppm  calculated, or ppmc,  to  indicate  this  is the
  highest possible  ppm obtainable. Any measurement  that  indicates a
  higher value must be in error, such as with Robert's measurements.

  Some of  the Ag+ and OH- ions will combine in  the  Nernst diffusion
  layer, as I have frequently discussed. This reduces the final ppm.

  Some losses occur when the trace contaminants in the dw flow  to the
  anode. With good dw, this should account for less than 1 ppm error.

  Some losses  can occur if the glass or electrodes  are contaminated,
  such as Paula's experience with vinegar.

  With low  current density, and stopping the process as  soon  as any
  oxide or  sludge appears on the electrodes, the resulting  cs should
  be close to, but not equal to, the calculated value. But it is still
  subject to problems with contamination and poor dw.

  The idea is to use the Faraday equations so you know how much silver
  was liberated.

  Then measure the actual ppm to see how much was lost in the process.
  The Hanna  PWT is probably the best method to measure  the  ppm, now
  that we know the conversion factor between uS and ppm is unity.

  But the calibration accuracy of the PWT is a serious issue.  Some of
  the uS measurements posted are clearly in error. The salt test shows
  this.

  After we know the PWT calibration is correct, we need figure out how
  to minimize  the  difference  between  the  calculated  and measured
  values to  optimize  the process. Eventually we will  reach  a point
  where no further optimization is possible.

  From Ivan's and Ken's data, this seems to be around 27 ppm.

  So any  measurements that indicate a higher ppm need to  be examined
  carefully.

  If I inadvertently omitted my standard caution, please forgive me. It
  is so obvious, I can't see how anyone can think otherwise.

  Are we on the same page now?

Best Regards,

Mike Monett


--
The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver.

Instructions for unsubscribing may be found at: http://silverlist.org

To post, address your message to: [email protected]

Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html

List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>