url: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/m63327.html
CS>Re: Measuring very high ppms
From: Jrowland
Date: Fri, 10 Oct 2003 00:33:13
Hi jr,
I'm beginning to see the problem. I'll try to answer your questions
in the shortest space possible. Sympatico has instituted new email
procedures that make it unusable. It is too slow.
>> ...I always use ppm calculated, or ppmc,
> Yes.
>> ...to indicate this is the highest possible ppm obtainable...
> You may inherently know this, but I believe this is the first time
> you have actually stated it.
Sorry, I thought it was obvious. All my work has been focused on
understanding ions and oxides and how they are produced. Clearly,
they have to come from somewhere.
> What or who's specific verification method of measurement would
> satisfy you? You have consistently begged-off getting any testing
> done, citing "too many variables".
You really don't need to get a lab test. It is only a snapshot and
does not show daily variations due to temperature, contaminants,
variations in the quality of the dw, and so on. Please see my
response to Stuff:
http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/m63347.html
I use the Faraday equations to time the brew, and stop it at the
first sign of sludge or deposits on the anodes. If the dw is not
acting up, the ppm will be a bit less than the calculated value.
How much less takes an educated guess. Most low current density cs
gives 95% ionic or more. Check Frank's reports, and some of the better
data from Ken and Ivan.
So for a calculated value of 22 ppmc, I subtract 10% to be
conservative and call it 20 ppm.
If I have any questions about the process, I do a quick salt test to
check. It quickly showed the discrepancy for two recent dw problems
I ran into.
The Hanna PWT would be an excellent method if I could find some way
to guarantee the calibration. Steve Young's idea to make resistive
standards might be an excellent solution.
Most of the time, I push the Godzilla generator to 34 ppmc and use
H2O2 to clear the yellow tint. I don't have any idea what the actual
ppm is, but I'm sure it is above 20 and probably below 27 ppm.
That's the hghest value Ivan and Ken have posted, and I don't want to
go above it unless I have real good data.
But it is strong and highly repeatable. Repeatability is the most
important thing about making cs. If it is not repeatable, you really
can't tell if it is doing the job, especially if you are older and
your immune system is degraded like the mold did to mine.
>> ...It is so obvious, I can't see how anyone can think otherwise.
> Pretend, just for a moment, you are a newbie to CS production.
That never really occurred to me. People are constantly coming and
going, and there is no way to guess how much background they may
have. Most of the explanations on the web are of little use or plain
wrong. I have no idea what preconceptions people might have, and
can't do much about it. I'm constantly learning more and doing new
experiments. They already take too long to explain to Ken and the
others. It would bore them to death if I had to start from the
beginning in each post.
>> Are we on the same page now?
> We're getting there... jr
Best Regards,
Mike Monett
--
The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver.
Instructions for unsubscribing may be found at: http://silverlist.org
To post, address your message to: [email protected]
Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html
List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>