The problem is that if the nutrient medium is a gel, and if the incubation is done while it is a gel, and the silver is inside the gel, and the culture is on top of the gell, or inside it as well, then the silver particles, which have no mobility will not be able to come in contact with the bacteria and kill them. Silver ions however can still diffuse and move around some inside the gel and have a much higher level of effectiveness..
So the big question is, was this incubated with an agar gel, or was an elevated temperature used so that it was a broth during incubation. Without more information I would assume it was a gel and the results are not valid. Marshall Trem wrote: > Marshall, > > Since there is now some doubt in my mind regarding your idea I have removed > the page from our site. > > Since I'm only an amateur at culture work (used to culture mushroom strains) > I fail to see why the test isn't valid. It seems he is trying to show that > when Staph is mixed with dilute hydrochloric acid and further mixed with > dilute silver of colloidal and ionic content that one set of cultures had a > better kill rate. I wasn't aware the test involved growing onto the plate. > I thought the plates were used only because they were a sterile medium that > would not inhibit growth and would not influence the kill rate. What am I > missing here? > > Trem > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "Marshall Dudley" <[email protected]> > To: <[email protected]> > Sent: Monday, March 28, 2005 8:48 AM > Subject: Re: CS>Ionic versus Colloidal > > > The link you provide on that page of the research done by Natural > > Immunogenics > > is interesting. At first I though, ah ha, we got some good data now. But > > unfortunately they have a very big problem with the protocol that > > completely > > invalidates their conculsion. The medium they used had 2% agar in it, > > which > > means they were working with a gel. As I have reported here before from > > experiments I had UT run, colloidal silver is almost totally ineffective > > when > > in a gel or other solid or semisolid medium where it has no modility. > > Ionic > > silver will still have some mobility though, so it is not surprising that > > it > > will kill, and the colloidal portion will not. > > > > I would like to see this experiment run again in a broth, that better > > represents the blood plasma, instead of a gel which is more representative > > of > > ones stool where we do not normally want it to kill. > > > > On that page you state: > > > > Please see the test results here. This should resolve the issue. It > > seems > > clear the ionic portion is more effective at killing pathogens. > > > > Unfotunately it shows that colloidal silver is ineffective an a gel, not > > that > > one is better at killing pathogens in a broth simulating the blood than > > the > > other. This is not news at all, I first reported this over 5 years ago. > > What I > > really find disturbing is that this test was run end of last year > > according to > > their date, 5 years after anyone who had researched it already knew that > > colloid was ineffective in agar, so they already knew what the result > > would be > > before doing the experiment. If they really want to give good information > > they > > should rerun the tests in a broth. > > > > Marshall > > > > Trem wrote: > > > >> I get many calls from prospective customers mentioning that they have > >> been > >> to Frank's site and wonder what the facts are. So, yesterday I placed > >> this > >> page > >> on our site to answer their questions by referring them to some > >> information > >> not tainted by my opinion. > >> > >> http://www.silvergen.com/ionic_versus_colloidal_silver.htm > >> > >> Trem > >> > >> ----- Original Message ----- > >> From: "Terry Chamberlin" <[email protected]> > >> To: <[email protected]> > >> Sent: Friday, March 25, 2005 9:28 AM > >> Subject: CS>CS debate > >> > >> > All this discussion of what happens when > >> > ionic/colloidal silver enters the body, what is > >> > happening in the stomach and then in the blood, how > >> > such-and-such cannot be happening or in fact must be > >> > happening reminds me of the solid, logical scientific > >> > proof that the bumblebee CANNOT fly. > >> > > >> > To read Frank's "scientific", "logical" "proof" that > >> > ionic silver is not worth taking is laughable, even > >> > pathetic, in the face of its obvious benefit against > >> > everything from colds to MS. > >> > > >> > Even Frank's responses here on this list have been > >> > disappointing. On his site he warns that ionic silver > >> > can cause argyria (a claim I have seen absolutely NO > >> > substantiation for whatsoever - cite to me ONE case, > >> > Frank), then abmits that it would take an amount none > >> > of the standard CS-brewers are even capable of > >> > brewing. > >> > > >> > Why does he then mention it? I am forced to conclude > >> > that he makes that point for the fear affect it has on > >> > those readers who don't notice his inconsistency, to > >> > scare them into buying his product. > >> > > >> > He might as well, as we regularly see the medical > >> > establishment do, report the possibility of Vitamin A > >> > overdose to scare you into buying his "special" kind > >> > of Vit A (without mentioning how most Vit A overdoses > >> > are from synthetic Vit A). In fact, his scare tactics > >> > to persuade you to buy his product and avoid all > >> > others sound remarkably similar to the tactics used by > >> > the medical establishment. (Eerie music, sculking men > >> > in black overcoats, "Is Frank an undercover agent for > >> > the Medical Mafia?") > >> > > >> > Nope, I sincerely doubt it. But using the same > >> > logically-dishonest, misdirecting, inuendo-laden > >> > approach as those who ARE agents for the bad guys does > >> > not create confidence in him or his product. > >> > > >> > If 10% of what Frank declares about the safety of > >> > ionic silver was true, there would be 500 cases per > >> > year of argyria, and the FDA would have made the > >> > brewing and/or drinking of anything with silver in it > >> > a felony. > >> > > >> > The worst part is that Frank's pseudo-scientific, > >> > unprovable, unsubstantiated claims make good > >> > propaganda for silver opponents to use, howeverever > >> > unrealistic they actually are. > >> > > >> > Frank, clue in to the disservice you are doing to the > >> > silver community. Selling your product is not the > >> > highest priority in life. Community and caring about > >> > others is. > >> > > >> > >> -- > >> The Silver List is a moderated forum for discussing Colloidal Silver. > >> > >> Instructions for unsubscribing are posted at: http://silverlist.org > >> > >> To post, address your message to: [email protected] > >> Silver List archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html > >> > >> Address Off-Topic messages to: [email protected] > >> OT Archive: http://escribe.com/health/silverofftopiclist/index.html > >> > >> List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]> > > > >

