Re: CS>Ionic versus Colloidal
From: Marshall Dudley
Date: Tue, 29 Mar 2005 11:52:19
http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/m79146.html
P.S. This is a repost - sympatico went clang again. Sorry if it is a
duplicate.
> Dan Nave wrote:
>> Re: CS>Ionic versus Colloidal
>> From: Marshall Dudley wrote:
>> Date: Mon, 28 Mar 2005 10:53:24
>> "M. G. Devour" wrote:
>>> So we are left with the unanswered question of whether some
>>> mechanism exists by which silver chloride -- or whatever other
>>> as yet undetermined species might exist -- may form an effective
>>> fraction in the complex environment of the blood.
>> <YES YES YES YES!
>> Why, then, do we not just use an appropriately small and diluted
>> dose of silver chloride instead of going through all the trouble
>> to make EIS?
>> I had suggested this idea before but there was no comment...
> Because that can give you argyria, and if I am right about the
> conversion of silver salts to silver particles in the blood,
> produce a few ineffective huge particles of silver instead of
> trillions of extremely small effective ones. With EIS you get the
> nucleation sites for plate out in the brew.
> Marshall
I am amused by the arguments produced recently. Silver ions are
converted to silver chloride as soon as they encounter salt or
hydrochloric acid in the body. There is no minimum solubility as
Marshall proposes. It all gets converted to silver chloride.
We all know Stan Jones got Argyria from drinking large doses of
silver chloride. When exposed to light, a photon knocks an electron
free from the chlorine, and the silver ion grabs it. Both atoms are
now free to go their separate ways, but the silver gets stuck in the
tissues and turns your skin blue. So silver chloride is bad because
it produces elemental silver particles in your body.
But then we read that ionic cs will not give you Argyria.
Interesting. With all the cs we drink over the years, surely some of
it must have stuck somewhere and we are all turning blue. But this
contradiction is never resolved.
The next thing we hear is Mesosilver is pure silver particles. Seems
like we just decided silver particles are bad since they give you
Argyria. It has to accumulate over time - the EPA and other
organizations give maximum lifetime doses. But this contradiction is
never resolved.
Next we hear that Mesosilver is very effective in killing pathogens.
It has to be true - the reports are publication quality.
But the reports never tell us that the 20ppm Mesosilver has an ionic
content of 3.9ppm. The reports also use a 75ppm version, but there
is no information on the ionic content. There has to be some - but
we don't know how much. So how do we know the killing results are
not due to the ion content? The times listed are certainly long
enough for silver ions to diffuse anywhere and slowly kill the
pathogen.
The 75ppm product is not available commercially. Perhaps the reason
is it definitely would produce Argyria. Is it fair to use a
non-available product to demonstrate the efficiency of the standard
one? I don't think so.
Next we hear that silver ions were never found in the blood, but the
ICP/AES did find silver in the blood serum. Interesting.
If you hold 1 oz of 20pm cs in your mouth for ten minutes, then spit
it out, the maximum possible concentration you can get in your blood
is 118 parts per billion. Of course, you never get 100% absorption.
The silver content mentioned in one of Frank's reports ranges from
28ppb to a bit over 100ppb. This corresponds well with the value
calculated above.
But we are supposed to believe the reason this could not be detected
with the Ion Selective Voltmeter is because it all converted to
silver chloride, which is bad or doesn't matter depending on which
page you are on.
Perhaps the reason the ion was not detected is the probe has a
minimum detection level. One commercially available probe has a
limit of 50 parts per billion - the same range as we are trying to
measure.
The probe is also affected by other ions, such as sodium. The
selectivity coefficients differ for each probe and ion combination.
So it is possible the interference from sodium would completely
overwhelm the response from the small amount of silver ions, so it
could not be detected.
The owner of the instrument knows the performance data. I asked
Frank for these parameters, but have not seen a response:
http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/m78996.html
So it's possible the attempt to measure the ion content was futile
in the first place. We are not given the information needed to tell.
The next amazing thing we learn is the key to everything is particle
surface area. There is no explanation - we just have to take this on
faith.
It turns out surface area is very important when you want to
increase the rate of a reaction. For example, if you want an aspirin
to dissolve faster, you break it into pieces. This increases the
surface area and it goes faster. Cookies bake faster than a single
large cake because their surface area is greater. There are other
methods of increasing the reaction rate. You can raise the
temperature. You can increase the concentration.
Perhaps the most significant way of increasing the reaction rate is
to use the correct ingredients. Marbles won't bake in cookies, no
matter how small you make the particles.
But surely the silver ion has to have the largest surface area.
Similarly, all the previous information on the killing power of
silver refers to the action of the ions. The British Columbia report
on environmental effect of silver shows the silver ion combines with
a sulphur ion in the bacteria, killing it.
We really don't know how silver ions kill bacteria and viruses, but
there are hundreds of protein pathways in bacteria. Often disabling
just one will kill it. There is a report on the number of silver
ions needed to kill one bacteria. I don't have the link handy, but
it may be something like 100,000. So we need lots of ions.
Everything in biology works with ions. There are no reactions
involving neutral particles. But Frank doesn't tell us how the pure
silver particles in Mesosilver can have any biological effect.
It could be related to the action of Silverlon bandages, which have
pure silver embedded in the fabric. But the description of Silverlon
tells us the silver is converted to ions by body fluids released in
the wound, and it is essential to wet the bandage with distilled
water to start the conversion.
if this is true, then Mesosilver could be converted to silver ions
in the body.
However, we now have the problem that silver ions are instantly
converted to silver chloride, and we have to start all over at the
beginning.
My head explodes when I try to figure this out. Why bother with all
this hokey-pokey when I can make my own highly ionic silver, and
watch it heal the damage caused by years of problems with mold
toxins?
There are many other examples of confusion, errors, and
contradictions, but Mike has indicated he wants this thread to end
so I will quit now.
On to more important things, like why does Trem's SG7 make such fine
cs?
Best Wishes,
Mike Monett
--
The Silver List is a moderated forum for discussing Colloidal Silver.
Instructions for unsubscribing are posted at: http://silverlist.org
To post, address your message to: [email protected]
Silver List archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html
Address Off-Topic messages to: [email protected]
OT Archive: http://escribe.com/health/silverofftopiclist/index.html
List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>