Mike,
I think this is what you wanted to see. Please note the test result photos
cannot be shown in plain text so you will have to go to the site for
viewing. http://tinyurl.com/3qb4v
You might also want to take a look at this page also.
http://tinyurl.com/4jff2
Trem
______________________________________________
Natural-Immunogenics Documentation Library
Comparative Bacteriology Analysis:
Particulate vs. Ionic Silver
December 22, 2004
Andrew Martin, B.S.
John W. Roberts, Ph.D.
Natural-Immunogenics Corp
Purpose
Claims have been made by the manufacturer of Mesosilver that suggest "ionic"
silver potency is compromised by Hydrochloric Acid (HCl) in the stomach, and
that only particulate silver (i.e. Mesosilver) can be effective in
inhibiting pathogenic microorganisms.
The hypothesis of Natural-Immunogenics, Corp. is that, contrary to the
claims above, only the ion is responsible for silver's antimicrobial
efficacy. Natural-Immunogenics, Corp.'s products (Argentyn 23 and Sovereign
Silver ) are composed in excess of 95% silver ions.
The purpose of this study is to compare the antibacterial efficacy of
Argentyn 23 Silver to that of Mesosilver . Both of these products were
exposed to the same amount (concentration) of HCl. Identical bacterial
concentrations and dilutions of two strains of Staphylococcus aureus (S-1
and S-2) were used to test each product. This testing was accomplished by
exposing healthy strains of the bacteria (in dilution series) to the two
products after adding 10µl of HCl solution (in various concentrations).
Materials and Methods
Summary:
The antibacterial activity of both Argentyn 23 and Mesosilver were compared
by treating healthy cultures of the bacterial strains, separately, with each
of the two products (to which was added 10µl of HCl solution, in various
concentrations, to make 1 ml samples of each).
Source, cultivation, and preparation of bacterial samples:
The YT media was autoclaved and poured into sterile plates and allowed to
dry.
Two strains of Staph received from the New York Hospital of Queens.
B14192 - wild type/ normal strain (S-1)
B14310 - antibiotic resistant MRSA (S-2)
The bacteria was grown on YT media for 16 to 24 hours before being
harvested.
A 3 mm confluent inoculum of S-1 was resuspended in 1,250µl of sterile, 17
to 18 MegOhm (M?) purified lab water.
Then a standard 10:1 dilution series was performed on each strain, using
sterile purified lab water
1/10, 1/100, 1/1,000, 1/10,000, and 1/100,000 dilutions of each stock
bacterial suspension were prepared.
The bacterial strain, S-2, was prepared identically, as was strain S-1.
Preparation of Test Media (YT):
Each 95mm sterile polystyrene culture plate (Petri dish) was filled with 5mm
of YT media (which consists of 0.5% NaCl, 0.6% yeast extract, 0.8% tryptone
and 2% agar).
Preparation of the silver products:
Argentyn 23 was diluted to 20 PPM (so as to have an equal concentration of
silver) using sterile, 18 MegOhm (M?) purified lab water.
Mesosilver was determined (separately, by atomic absorption) to have a
concentration of 20 PPM.
9 parts of Argentyn 23 (final concentration 18 PPM) and one part of HCl (33,
or 44, or 77 PPM, finally diluted to 3, 4, and 7 PPM, respectively) were
added to eachother and mixed.
Mesosilver and HCl were added to eachother and mixed, as above.
Treatment of Bacterial Strains with Silver Products
10 µl. of the silver product/ HCl mixture (9µl. each of Silver product and 1
µl. of HCl) were added to 90µl. of each of the sets of dilutions (1/100
through 100,000) of the two bacterial strain, above.
The mixture was agitated and allowed to react until spotted onto the YT
plate.
One 10µl sample of each mixture of bacterial dilution/Silver/HCl of Strain
S-1 was spotted onto the YT plates.
One 10µl sample of each mixture of bacterial dilution with Silver/HCl of
Strain S-2 was spotted onto YT plates.
The exposure times were limited to 4 or 8 minutes, respectively, for each
set of treatments.
This protocol was performed identically for Argentyn 23 and Mesosilver.
Negative control plate (positive growth) - No silver/HCl being added to S-1
or S-2 cultures. Sterile, purified water replaced the volume (10µl) of
Silver/HCl.
Positive control plate - Treatment of bacterial strains with respective
silver products without HCl.
Plates then placed in a 35°C to 37°C incubator overnight (16 to 24 hours).
Results
Qualitative results can easily be seen on each plate.
The negative control for S-1 grew out 4.5 spots, represented by (++++ ½ ),
as did the negative control for S-2. These samples did not contain the
silver or silver/ HCl mix. A (-) represents no Staph growth and (1/2)
represents some Staph growth. The efficacy of the silver/HCl in the various
ratios can be compared by the number of (+) vs. (-) spots observed.
The positive control (silver and NO HCl) for S-1 and S-2. This should have
shown the greatest degree of kill/inhibition (since there was no HCl to
degrade/inactivate the silver.
A + designation is given for complete or near-complete spot-growth. A ½ is
given for mottled/speckled appearing growth. A ½ is given for only a few
spots of growth. A - is given for NO growth. The right-most + or - character
represents a 1/100,000 dilution of the stock bacterial suspension; the
left-most + or - represents a 1/10 dilution. The more - characters from the
right, the more potent the antibacterial activity. The negative control
(representing NO silver/HCl treatment should show 4 + and one ½ characters,
demonstrating the viability of the untreated bacterial employed.
Inhibition results
S-1 4min S-2 4min S-1 8min S-2 8min
Negativecontrol ++++ ½ ++++ ½ ++++ ½ ++++ ½
Argentyn23, 0 HCl - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Ag23 w/ 3ppm HCl +/- - - - - +/- - - - - - - - - - ½ - - - -
Ag23 w/ 4ppm HCl + - - - - + - - - - + - - - - + - - - -
Ag23 w/ 7ppm HCl + - - - - + - - - - + - - - - + - - - -
Mesosilver, 0 HCl +½ ½ +/- - ++½ +/- - + ½ ½ - - + ½ ½ - -
Meso w/ 3ppm HCl +++½ +/- +++½ +/- ++ ½ ½ - ++++ ½
Meso w/ 4ppm HCl ++++ ½ ++++ ½ +++ ½ - ++++ ½
Meso w/ 7ppm HCl ++++ ½ ++++ ½ ++++ ½ ++++ ½
The photographs of the results for the 4 minute exposure of the Silver/HCl
(at 3 PPM) are shown below. The observations of the 4 PPM and 7 PPM and for
both 4 and 8 minute exposures of Silver/HCl mixtures were virtually
identical to those for the illustrated 3 PPM HCl (shown below).
Discussion
The concentrations of HCl added to each of the two products were such that
the concentrations of HCl in the final volumes would be 3ppm, 4ppm, and
7ppm. The range of concentration was determined in an earlier experiment.
These concen-trations were selected because, if the HCl were to react with
the silver, the conversion of Ag+ to AgCl would not make HCl the limiting
reagent. The amount of remaining active silver would be the true limiting
factor.
The following conclusions can be drawn from the data:
It is evident from the results that the antimicrobial efficacy of both
products decreases as the concentration of HCl increases .
When comparing the plates where no HCl was added, it can be seen that
Argentyn 23T has far greater antibacterial efficacy than MesosilverT .
Mesosilver'sT antibacterial efficacy is almost negated by adding just 4ppm
of HCl, whereas Argentyn23T 's antibacterial efficacy is only slightly
reduced but still strong, even with the addition of 7 PPM HCl.
Adding HCl to the silver products, causes the chloride ion to bind the
silver ion forming Silver chloride (AgCl). Since Argentyn23T is primarily an
ionic product there is still a sufficient number of Ag+ ions left to kill
the bacteria.
MesosilverT on the other hand is primarily particulate in nature, and has
significantly little (compared to Argentyn 23T ) silver ion content. Once
the silver ions in MesosilverT react with the chloride ions, they become
almost completely inactivated. We see an almost complete loss of
antimicrobial activity when MesosilverT is exposed to even modest quantities
of HCl.
This experiment serves as proof that it is the active, available silver
ions - not the particulate silver - in which the antibacterial property of
silver resides.
----- Original Message -----
From: "M. G. Devour" <[email protected]>
To: <[email protected]>
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2005 6:52 PM
Subject: Re: CS>Ionic versus Colloidal
Trem, please save me going to the site: Where and when is the microbe
introduced into the experiment. Diluted into the pure water before
addition of the other stuff?
So it's a go/no go test, basically, showing whether the product will
produce 100% kill within a certain period of time?
About the only difference would be if the mesosilver was given less
time than it needs to complete the kill, while the ionic material
happened to kill faster under the conditions. How much time are we
talking about?
Be well,
Mike D.
[Mike Devour, Citizen, Patriot, Libertarian]
[[email protected] ]
[Speaking only for myself... ]
--
The Silver List is a moderated forum for discussing Colloidal Silver.
Instructions for unsubscribing are posted at: http://silverlist.org
To post, address your message to: [email protected]
Silver List archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html
Address Off-Topic messages to: [email protected]
OT Archive: http://escribe.com/health/silverofftopiclist/index.html
List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>