Mike Monett wrote:

> Re: CS>Ionic versus Colloidal
> From: Marshall Dudley
> Date: Tue, 29 Mar 2005 11:52:19
> http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/m79146.html
>
> P.S. This is a repost - sympatico went clang again. Sorry if it is a
> duplicate.
>
>   > Dan Nave wrote:
>
>   >> Re: CS>Ionic versus Colloidal
>
>   >> From: Marshall Dudley wrote:
>   >> Date: Mon, 28 Mar 2005 10:53:24
>
>   >> "M. G. Devour" wrote:
>
>   >>> So we  are  left with the unanswered  question  of  whether some
>   >>> mechanism exists  by which silver chloride -- or  whatever other
>   >>> as yet undetermined species might exist -- may form an effective
>   >>> fraction in the complex environment of the blood.
>
>   >> <YES YES YES YES!
>
>   >> Why, then, do we not just use an appropriately small  and diluted
>   >> dose of silver chloride instead of going through all  the trouble
>   >> to make EIS?
>
>   >> I had suggested this idea before but there was no comment...
>
>   > Because that  can  give you argyria, and if I am  right  about the
>   > conversion of  silver  salts  to silver  particles  in  the blood,
>   > produce a  few  ineffective huge particles  of  silver  instead of
>   > trillions of extremely small effective ones. With EIS you  get the
>   > nucleation sites for plate out in the brew.
>
>   > Marshall
>
>   I am  amused  by the arguments produced  recently.  Silver  ions are
>   converted to  silver  chloride  as soon as  they  encounter  salt or
>   hydrochloric acid  in  the body. There is no  minimum  solubility as
>   Marshall proposes. It all gets converted to silver chloride.

Where did I say it does not all get converted to silver chloride?  Yes, it
does all get converted to silver chloride.  Also silver chloride is not
totally soluble either, so there is limited solubility.

>
>
>   We all  know  Stan Jones got Argyria from  drinking  large  doses of
>   silver chloride. When exposed to light, a photon knocks  an electron
>   free from the chlorine, and the silver ion grabs it. Both  atoms are
>   now free to go their separate ways, but the silver gets stuck in the
>   tissues and turns your skin blue. So silver chloride is  bad because
>   it produces elemental silver particles in your body.
>

Silver chloride will become metallic silver in the body, and will plate out
on any particles that are present.  As you say, Stan Jones is proof of
that.  That is why the particle portion of EIS is so important, so it will
plate out on them making them slightly larger than on particles formed in
the skin from photoreduction causing argyria.

>
>   But then  we  read  that   ionic   cs  will  not  give  you Argyria.

Yes, I have explained this about a dozen times now.  The colloidal portion
of EIS  acts as a prophylactic against argyria. Nothing unusual or
unexpected here.

>
>   Interesting. With all the cs we drink over the years, surely some of
>   it must  have stuck somewhere and we are all turning blue.  But this
>   contradiction is never resolved.

THERE IS NO CONTRADICTION! EVERYTHING IS AS EXPECTED FROM THEORY!

>
>
>   The next thing we hear is Mesosilver is pure silver particles. Seems
>   like we  just decided silver particles are bad since  they  give you
>   Argyria. It  has  to  accumulate  over  time  -  the  EPA  and other
>   organizations give maximum lifetime doses. But this contradiction is
>   never resolved.

Who just decided that?  I think it was ONLY you.  Argyria is caused by
silver particles growing until they get stuck in the skin. Silver particles
grow by the photo developing process from silver salts.  Silver particles
are already reduced, like a developed photo.  A developed photo never gets
darker, if anything they fade. It requires silver salts to produce argyria,
not silver particles.  If the particle is small enough to get into the
body, then it is small enough to get out.

>
>
>   Next we hear that Mesosilver is very effective in killing pathogens.
>   It has to be true - the reports are publication quality.
>
>   But the reports never tell us that the 20ppm Mesosilver has an ionic
>   content of  3.9ppm. The reports also use a 75ppm version,  but there
>   is no  information on the ionic content. There has to be some  - but
>   we don't  know how much. So how do we know the  killing  results are
>   not due  to  the ion content? The times  listed  are  certainly long
>   enough for  silver  ions  to diffuse anywhere  and  slowly  kill the
>   pathogen.
>

I believe that both kill, but there still needs to be more experimentation
on this.

>
>   The 75ppm product is not available commercially. Perhaps  the reason
>   is it  definitely  would  produce  Argyria.

Can you tell me any way that particles of silver could cause argyria
without becoming silver salts first?  And any way that silver salts could
cause argyria if there is a large amount of silver particles available for
them to plate out on in the blood?

> Is  it  fair  to  use a
>   non-available product to demonstrate the efficiency of  the standard
>   one? I don't think so.
>
>   Next we hear that silver ions were never found in the blood, but the
>   ICP/AES did find silver in the blood serum. Interesting.

That is fully expected as well.  If silver salts reduce to silver particles
in the blood, by plating out on any present particles, then this is the
result fully expected.  That they plate out on silver particles is proven
by the fact that if you do not have other particles for it to plate out on,
argyria can result.  All of this supports the theory that silver salts
plate out on silver particles, or become silver particles in the blood
rather quickly.

>
>
>   If you hold 1 oz of 20pm cs in your mouth for ten minutes, then spit
>   it out, the maximum possible concentration you can get in your blood
>   is 118 parts per billion. Of course, you never get 100% absorption.

I am assuming this is computed from the ratio of 1 oz of 20 ppm vs the
amount of blood one typically has..

>
>
>   The silver  content mentioned in one of Frank's reports  ranges from
>   28ppb to  a  bit over 100ppb. This corresponds well  with  the value
>   calculated above.
>
>   But we are supposed to believe the reason this could not be detected
>   with the  Ion  Selective Voltmeter is because  it  all  converted to
>   silver chloride,  which is bad or doesn't matter depending  on which
>   page you are on.

Huh? The ionic portion may become silver chloride, but the colloidal
portion will remain a colloid.  Noting unexpected here, since the colloid
should remain a colloid.  The reason it cannot be detected is because
silver particles are not detected by an ionic probe, they are not ionic.
Nothing surprising here either.

>
>
>   Perhaps the  reason  the  ion was not detected is  the  probe  has a
>   minimum detection  level.  One commercially  available  probe  has a
>   limit of  50 parts per billion - the same range as we are  trying to
>   measure.

What ion?  You are talking in circles.  Mesosilver is mostly colloidal,
which will not register. The ionic portion may be below the limit of the
ion meter, but there are apparently other papers that also found that ionic
silver could not be found in the blood when silver salts are taken, and
that the half life of ionic silver is about 7.5 seconds. None of these
results are surprising, in fact they are what I would expect.

>
>
>   The probe  is  also  affected by other  ions,  such  as  sodium. The
>   selectivity coefficients differ for each probe and  ion combination.
>   So it  is  possible the interference  from  sodium  would completely
>   overwhelm the  response from the small amount of silver ions,  so it
>   could not be detected.

Maybe, I am not familiar with that problem.

>
>
>   The owner  of  the instrument knows the  performance  data.  I asked
>   Frank for these parameters, but have not seen a response:
>
>     http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/m78996.html
>
>   So it's  possible the attempt to measure the ion content  was futile
>   in the first place. We are not given the information needed to tell.
>
>   The next amazing thing we learn is the key to everything is particle
>   surface area. There is no explanation - we just have to take this on
>   faith.
>

This has been explained in a number of papers.  First you have to figure
out how silver particles kill.  I think it is because silver is an
oxidizing catalyst, and it is well known that the activity of a catalyst is
completely and linearly dependent on the surface area of the catalyst.
That the activity would be proportion to the surface area is what would be
expected.  Silver that is inside a particle and not exposed cannot do
anything, so once again only those that are exposed on the surface can be
active.

>
>   It turns  out  surface  area  is very  important  when  you  want to
>   increase the rate of a reaction. For example, if you want an aspirin
>   to dissolve  faster,  you break it into pieces.  This  increases the
>   surface area  and it goes faster. Cookies bake faster than  a single
>   large cake  because their surface area is greater.  There  are other
>   methods of  increasing  the   reaction   rate.   You  can  raise the
>   temperature. You can increase the concentration.
>
>   Perhaps the most significant way of increasing the reaction  rate is
>   to use  the correct ingredients. Marbles won't bake  in  cookies, no
>   matter how small you make the particles.
>
>   But surely the silver ion has to have the largest surface area.

That is true, and two silver atoms have the largest surface area for a
colloid.  But an ion of silver and an atom of silver behave completely
differently.  For instance, silver ions are not catalytic at all, but very
small clumps of silver atoms are.

>
>
>   Similarly, all  the  previous information on  the  killing  power of
>   silver refers to the action of the ions. The British Columbia report
>   on environmental effect of silver shows the silver ion combines with
>   a sulphur ion in the bacteria, killing it.

Silver atoms will also react with sulfur, it is called tarnishing. As I
said silver ions and silver particles both seem to kill bacteria, but the
mechanism is most likely different.  The ions likely kill by reacting with
sulfur as you point out. The particles most likely kill by being an
oxidizing catalyst,  and by disturbing the electrostatic equilibrium of a
pathogen.  They both kill, and one may be more effective on a certain
pathogen than the other. However the ions are used up in such a battle, but
the particles are unchanged so they can continue killing until they are
expelled.  That is I believe one reason CS and EIS is so much more
effective than normal antibiotics, it keeps on killing without being
consumed.

>
>
>   We really don't know how silver ions kill bacteria and  viruses, but
>   there are hundreds of protein pathways in bacteria.  Often disabling
>   just one  will  kill it. There is a report on the  number  of silver
>   ions needed  to kill one bacteria. I don't have the link  handy, but
>   it may be something like 100,000. So we need lots of ions.

But if it is being killed by a silver particle due to the catalytic
oxidization, then it only takes one. If it kills by electrical disturbance,
then it only takes one.  And after it kills, it is still there to kill
again.

>   Everything in  biology  works  with  ions.  There  are  no reactions
>   involving neutral particles. But Frank doesn't tell us how  the pure
>   silver particles in Mesosilver can have any biological effect.

Where do you get the idea that everything in biology works with ions? If
that were true it would be impossible to get any calories from sugars or
any carbohydrate, they do not form ions.  Also gasoline, benzene, ether,
and all hydrocarbons would be harmless, they do not form ions, but are
deadly poisonous to pathogens, as well as humans.  If it were impossible
for a non-ionic substance to kill, then bug spray, all hydrocarbon poisons,
alcohols,  and hundreds of other toxic compounds would not kill anything,
but we know they do.

>
>
>   It could be related to the action of Silverlon bandages,  which have
>   pure silver embedded in the fabric. But the description of Silverlon
>   tells us the silver is converted to ions by body fluids  released in
>   the wound,  and  it is essential to wet the  bandage  with distilled
>   water to start the conversion.
>

Silverlon bandages primarily use ions for the healing action.  Everyone
agrees that ions are what is needed for the dedifferentiation and
redifferentiation to take place. Nothing surprising here.  Those bandages
use a current to produce the ions just like we do when we make EIS I
believe.

>
>   if this  is true, then Mesosilver could be converted to  silver ions
>   in the body.
>

How?

>
>   However, we  now  have the problem that  silver  ions  are instantly
>   converted to  silver chloride, and we have to start all over  at the
>   beginning.
>

No, silver ions are converted to silver chloride rather quickly.. The
silver chloride reduces to silver particles rather quickly, and it pretty
well stops there. That is why the silveron bandages must continually
produce the ions

>
>   My head explodes when I try to figure this out. Why bother  with all
>   this hokey-pokey  when  I can make my own highly  ionic  silver, and
>   watch it  heal  the  damage caused by years  of  problems  with mold
>   toxins?

Why is it hard to get a handle on it? All the experiments seem to support
the theory, and are predicted by the theory.  And highly ionic EIS works
great. The discussions are trying to figure out why it works, why it does
not cause argyria and so forth.  The theories I have proposed appear to
answer all the above questions, in fact predict the results of the
experiments correctly. I am not disputing that highly ionic silver works,
and works great.  But when someone (the doctor, FDA or whatever) comes up
and says that highly ionic silver is a dissolved silver compound, and
silver compounds cause argyria, we better know why that is wrong. Now I
think we do, and can make a case that EIS does NOT cause argyria because of
the prophylactic effect of the accompanying particles.

>
>
>   There  are   many   other   examples   of   confusion,   errors, and
>   contradictions, but  Mike has indicated he wants this thread  to end
>   so I will quit now.

What confusion. I see nothing unexplained, confusing, or not predicted by
theory in any of the above you have written.

>
>
>   On to more important things, like why does Trem's SG7 make such fine
>   cs?

Low current per square inch of electrode, polarity reversing, stirring,
electrode spacing.

Marshall

>
>
> Best Wishes,
>
> Mike Monett
>
> --
> The Silver List is a moderated forum for discussing Colloidal Silver.
>
> Instructions for unsubscribing are posted at: http://silverlist.org
>
> To post, address your message to: [email protected]
> Silver List archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html
>
> Address Off-Topic messages to: [email protected]
> OT Archive: http://escribe.com/health/silverofftopiclist/index.html
>
> List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>