Hi, >>But, again, HOW does the edge proxy know that the UA actually will use CRLF? >>If it doesn't know, it may use short >>registration timer. > >it DOES NOT NEED KNOW, because the UA knows and uses short registration >interval. So, you are saying the following: if the UA does not support CRLF the UA itself will include a short registration interval in the REGISTER request? That is not standardized behavior either, and I am not sure that is how UAs work.
>>>"It is RECOMMENDED that the UA uses CRLF for TCP keep-alive even if >>>the UA doesn't receive keep=true, unless the UA receives a >>>registration refresh timer value which is equal or less than the UA's >>>default keep-alive interval in which case the registration refreshes >>>will act as keep-alives." >> >>I think that is what Juha proposed some e-mails ago. > >i didn't say anything about register timers. i said that tcp UA should >send CRLFs even if it does not get back CRLF. but now when we have >thought this more, because tcp UA anyway sends CRLFs, it makes no sense >to try to negotiate it. so please limit your keep protocol to udp UAs >only. You said the following: "you can write that if registration interval would be as short as default keepalive interval then it is not recommended to send keepalives." Regards, Christer _______________________________________________ Sip mailing list https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sip This list is for NEW development of the core SIP Protocol Use [EMAIL PROTECTED] for questions on current sip Use [EMAIL PROTECTED] for new developments on the application of sip
