In a message dated 05/30/2001 10:12:43 PM Central Daylight Time,
[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:
> There was no more than 20 to 30 minutes of discussion needed in Chicago to
> have a ruling made by the CD on our launch technique. BTW, this would not
> have had to happen if the FAI/CIAM had changed the rules in a sensible
> fashion, but they didn't.
>
> There are only a few F3J contests in the US each year, and we had to put
> our technique to the current rule book right now, before Nats and the US
> team selections, in the realm of a real contest, there is no other way to
> do it. The way the rules are written now, even if they are written
poorly,
> allow us to launch the way we did, and I can and have made a very strong
> case for it, and now it is on record as being accepted in a US
> contest. There is no "spirit" of the rules, or "intent", just the
> official rule book and the rules it provides. If we did something wrong,
> some one will have to show us why with the rules from the current official
> rule book. So far, no one has been able to do that.
>
> If people want to obey the "spirit" of F3J, then why don't you all protest
> the rules to go back to 150m of braided line kite tows with open bay
models
> 2 and 3 channel models like the English had planned it to be.
>
>
> Jim
> Downers Grove, IL
Hi Jim, Monday was fun, eh? :) To tell you the truth, I really didn't get a
chance to watch how the towing went at your end of the field. I was either
throwing or flying a plane for every flight group (I actually got pulled off
my feet once, when the runners were kicked at 4 seconds. I was ready to throw
at 1 and that last second pulled me over. I just managed to hang on and let
go at the start of working time and the plane got off straight!) I did hear
the clinking at the start of the day when you guys pounded the stakes in.
That's when our team decided to go over and see what was happening. I kind of
wish I hadn't, 'cause the time we spent talking about it probably cost us a
round of flying when the last round ended at 3:20. Those lunch breaks are
killers, though! BTW, fantastic lunches for all three days, especially when
those Subs showed up on Saturday in the rain! It gave us the lift we needed
to take down the field in the rain. Thanks Debbie, and everybody else who
helped pull off this contest. We had lots of help from guys like Al Zolecki,
Tom Tock, Steve Moskal, Don Smith and Stan Watson ( know I'm forgetting
someone, sorry). Any way, we decided to endure your tow technique without
protest, I guess that is a sort of acceptance. We wanted to fly as I'm sure
you did! I did attend the team captains meeting and heard the CD's opinion on
the matter, and respect the reasoning behind it, but since there was no
formal protest, I don't know if that represents a ruling. Maybe our
acquiescence set some sort of precedent, I don't know, but that leaves us in
the unpleasant position of not really knowing anything more about its
legality until the NATS or *gulp* Team Select, the stakes (ha ha) being
raised incrementally. Are we playing chess or flying toy planes? I know Jimmy
Mac stated he'd fly zero's all day in the interest of safety, so I didn't
really appreciate him getting thouski's all day long! :) That 9 whatever in
the 4th round was masterful. I'm not sure what the tow technique had to do
with it, he could probably beat both of by hand launching that Artemis of
his. Our team used pulley tows and direct to the plane tows and we seemed to
get competitively high, with the added bonus that there was very little
conversation about it:) . See ya at the Fred!
Bill Wingstedt
RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News. Send "subscribe" and
"unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]