Steve,
The underlying problem with allowing any ground based object (say a
stake) is that you have to submit guidelines for use. And then even if
followed, they may not be enough! For example, a REALLY soft muddy field
may require 3-4 redundant stakes, along with constant resetting of the
pulley/stake/fixed object. Yet a dry hard desert field may only need a
single backup. No governing body can propose a rule that opens up a legal
(in the US and UK at least) situation, as well as a simple safety one. If
the rules say "stake with 2 backup stakes, meeting a minimum sixe of X and
installed in method Y" then they have defined a new standard. Is it safe?
Well that remains to be seen.
As to the F3b argument (F3b uses stakes with pulleys). There has been
situations of the stakes pulling out of the ground, EVEN with backups. The
proximity of the people to the stakes is much greater (200 meters) so
luckially there has been no deaths that I have heard of (so far). But the
danger is there. A F3j similar setup that does "come apart" will have
people within several meters!
The simple fact is that any unattended device can and will fail
eventually. That is a simple and undeniable fact. Yes you can overdesign
the setup, but eventually it will fail. At some point the risk of failure
becomes acceptably low, but who knows what that is, and who can design a
rule that accounts for this. We already have different feelings on "safe
towing", so what constitutes a safe fixed object? The only system that is
close to being truly safe is a massive object that regardless of it's
attachment to the earth, can support the force on it simply due to friction
and gravity. A car for example! Not trying to be excessive, but it is
true. A freestanding massive "stake" is the only truly safe situation
because regardless of the setup or installation, no amount of pull on the
line can move it. Say 1000lb weight/tiedown?
And Jim, while I agree that the pics may have been there for a while, BARCS
is not the FAI or the ultimate authority on towing. Also, that is YOUR pic,
not a separate entitiy, so sure you will think that supports your assertion.
It's your work!
Jason
----- Original Message -----
From: "Steven Meyer" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Cc: "Steve Kaluf" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "James V. Bacus"
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Sent: Friday, June 01, 2001 8:39 AM
Subject: RE: [RCSE] F3J new tow rules in a contest
>
> Another interesting comment. (bottom of page)
> http://home.clara.net/barcs/stakeagainst.htm#SilvaR
>
> Seems like there is an avoidance of dissecting the accident to determine
> what conditions contributed to the situation. A quick conclusion is
> obvious that outlawing one man tows would contribute a higher level of
> safety than the prior issue.
>
> Steve
>
> At 12:53 AM 6/1/2001 -0500, James V. Bacus wrote:
> >Too all that are still interested in F3J...
> >
> >I would like to show you all an announcement about the F3J rule change
> >from the UK CIAM delegate, Nick Neve. This can be found on the BARCS web
> >site at http://www.barcs.co.uk
> >
> >There are also diagrams of all the launch methods available under the new
> >rules, including the one we used in Chicago last weekend. This has been
> >up on their web site literally for months, I am surprised that this
> >brought so much recent attention.
> >
> >...
>
> Steve Meyer http://SOARchicago.com/stmeyer/
> [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> S.O.A.R. Web Page http://SOARchicago.com/
> Now with Message Boards http://SOARchicago.com/discus/
>
>
> RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News. Send "subscribe"
and "unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News. Send "subscribe" and
"unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]