Steven,
    The vectors and line speed issues are actually very similar.  In using
"real world" situatsion to explain things, lets look at hte difference
between a straight tow and Jim's/SOAR setup.  I totally understand your
comments on line speed, but remember, there are MANY other variables (wind
gradients, force vectors, line length, lift vectors, plane velocity,
apparent wind, etc) that come into play.  But lets move on.

    What is the reason for using a pulley?  In a 2 man pulley tow, the main
reason is to increase line speed for the first 1/3 or so of the launch
during light or no wind.  During the first part of the tow the lift vector
of the plan only points slightly "up".  The majority of hte lift that is
generated is in a horizontal plane, not a vertical one.  So the goal is to
increase the total amount of lift, as well as the plane's speed in order to
quickly get the plane aloft and into a position where the plane's lift
vectors are oriented better to gain altitude.  So the first 1/3 of the
launch, the line speed (and coresponding plane speed) generates all the
altitude.
    The next 1/3 of launch has the plane at around a 45 or so degree climb
angle to the ground.  The plane's lift vector is approaching vertical once
you add in the "apparent wind" (go to a sailing book to get a definition on
this).  Often in windy conditions, the towers are stopped during this phase,
and even a two man pulley tow in light wind can be stopped.  The line force
is still there, but the difference is now that the plane's acceleration has
stopped (or slowed) and hte lift vector is finally close to opposite of
gravity.  So more of the line force can be placed into generating lift,
resulting in an increase in line tension.  Often a 2 man pulley tow can be
stopped in light or greater wind!  A straight tow the people finally feel
tension here.
    The last section is the zoom.  This part turns the line tension into
airplane speed.  Basiclly no amount of running will contribute to the
plane's speed...it is already going to fast.  So it is 100% line
tension/force.  The resultant height is a combination of the plane + line
length + airplane speed.  More line left out means the plane is higher at
the beginning of the zoom.  More speed = more vertical velocity.

    So when comparing the two tows (straight vs Jim's) you look at the three
sections.
        - section one - initial launch.  No difference at all here.  In both
cases line speed is equal, plane velocity is similar and the force vectors
are about the same.  Some difference is apparent as the plane climbs because
the pulley shortens the line to the plane, but again, the main reason for
using hte pulley is to increase line speed.  Jim's use does not increase the
line speed during this initial launch section, so the net gain is minimal if
any.
        - section two - climb.  As before, most of the lift vectors are
pointing up here.  Line tension is the key, combined with line length.  We
want to climb as high as possible, as fast as possible.  Shortening the line
has decreased the arc length for Jim's plane, so the plane will see a slight
gain in velocity, but at the cost of launch height.  The 2 man straight tow
is still working on a 150meter or so line length, Jim may be down to around
130 now (based on what I saw during their tower's runs).  The force is still
approx the same since as we talked about before, the tension is often enough
in wind to stop the towers.  In light wind Jim may have a slight advantage
here because with the shorter arc they can get a higher plane velocity.
        - section three - zoom.  This converts the line tension into plane
speed.  Jim's method may have slightly more plane speed on exiting the zoom.
Again, they are still handicapped by the plane's height...up to 15-20 meters
lower than a straight tow at this point.  So yes, marginally higher plane
velocity can make up for some of the plane height loss, but not fully.

    In the end, I state again, there is minimal difference between the two
(Jim's launch method and a straight tow).  The main difference is that there
is again a fixed object that could be launched if improperly used.  Not that
I thought they did anything wrong, but again, the safety risk is raised over
a 2 man tow, with little or no gain.  From Jim's (and others) own
admissions, they were not launching as high as many of hte other teams, with
the highest being a straight tow group!  So again, I question the reasoning
of safety, when the safety rish is higher over a comparable launch method.

Jason Werner

----- Original Message -----
From: "Steven Meyer" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: "Jason Werner" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Cc: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "James V. Bacus" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Sent: Sunday, June 03, 2001 12:20 PM
Subject: Re: [RCSE] F3J new tow rules in a contest


> At 11:57 PM 6/1/2001 -0400, Jason Werner wrote:
>
>
> >First of all, we all agree that the stake/pulley as used by you all gains
no
> >advantage mechanically over a straight tow.
>
> Jason, No I do not agree with your assessment.
>
> Without getting into a physics lesson you need to look at force vectors
> when the plane is in the air.   You are assuming the plane never gains any
> altitude with your assumption of line speed. That is the only time both
> methods are equal.
>
> To make it easier to understand look at the line speeds relative to the
> plane if the plane is directly over head.  Direct tow will be ZERO while a
> pulley will be equal to the runners speed.  Unless you have a hole to jump
> in the direct tow line speed keeps decreasing the planes gains altitude.
>
>
> Steve Meyer  http://SOARchicago.com/stmeyer/
> [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> S.O.A.R. Web Page http://SOARchicago.com/
>
>
>

RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News.  Send "subscribe" and 
"unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to