No Way!! For the same package size decent (Sanyo) nicads have higher terminal
voltage under load, lower internal resistance, faster dependable charge and
discharge rates and a much longer charge retention time.

I will admit that NiMH cells have more capacity per volume than NiCads but you
must use it within a day or so and can't get it out at high rates with high
terminal voltage.

Stick any AA NiMh cells you can get in a digital camera and put it in your
pocket for a month - then try to take 8 or 10 pictures with flash, Didn't
work did it? Now try the same thing with a pair of 650 to 850 mAh NiCads.
No Problem getting the pictures!

NiMh cells are fine if you charge every day, don't need high terminal voltage,
and have no need for real reliability. Great product for mp3 players but
not for anything critical.

You can get NiCads with some of the same problems as NiMh cells if you pick
the ones that have boosted capacity by using foam plates to increase the
capacity.
-- 
Dick Barker
Port Angeles, WA
20 years of battery evaluation for defibs.
- Turning HLG Around - 



>I've found that the best and most convenient choice for AA receiver packs are
>the Energizer 2300 or 2500 MAH NiMh cells available from local department
>stores for around $10 per four-pack. I use them in all my sailplanes and
>radios and have never had a pack come close to reaching a discharged state.
>(And that's even after a long and extremely enjoyable day of slope soaring on
>the east coast of Florida, such as our club had yesterday.) 
>
>It's time to face the fact that NiCd cells are now essentially obsolete. They
>may have had some advantages over the early NiMh cells, but modern cells are
>available with equal or lower internal resistances, at least equal
>dependability and lifetimes, and much greater capacity. 
>
>Mike
RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News.  Send "subscribe" and 
"unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]  Please note that subscribe and 
unsubscribe messages must be sent in text only format with MIME turned off.  
Email sent from web based email such as Hotmail and AOL are generally NOT in 
text format

Reply via email to