From GRIST

Coal gasification: "clean coal" or subsidy-hungry boondoggle?

http://gristmill.grist.org/story/2006/4/12/173831/90

 

Posted by David Roberts at 10:44 AM on 13 Apr 2006 

Governing magazine has an excellent, compact overview of current developments 
in coal. If you're hazy on gasification this, coal-to-liquid that, and 
Fischer-Tropsch the other, I recommend it. 

With oil and natural-gas prices rising and coal in plentiful supply, it's more 
or less inevitable that coal's going to get used, so it makes sense that (some) 
enviro organizations are biting the bullet and joining the push for the 
cleanest possible applications. 

There is reason for cautious optimism. Coal mining is destructive as hell, but 
in places like northeastern Pennsylvania -- where the article focuses, and 
where the first U.S. coal-to-liquid plant will be built starting this Spring -- 
there's waste coal laying all over the place, leaching acid into groundwater 
(the legacy of pre-regulatory coal mining). The plant will gather that coal as 
feedstock and replace it with solid waste covered in soil, thereby creating 
farmland or forest. 

 

Converting coal to a synthetic gas -- "gasification," which involves heating it 
alongside oxygen to 2,000 F -- has its advantages. Most importantly, once 
coal's converted to a gas, it's fairly straightforward to remove pollutants. 
Mercury, sulfur, and particulates can be stripped out and sold commercially.

Via the Fischer-Tropsch process, the gas can be reconstituted into a variety of 
liquid fuels, which can sub for oil in heating homes or fueling vehicles. (The 
Penn. plant will produce low-sulfur diesel, which Gov. Ed Rendell has pledged 
to buy for the state's vehicles.) This is why gasification boosters, including 
Rendell and Montana Gov. Brian Schweitzer, play the energy-independence card. 

The gas can also sub for natural gas, fueling "integrated gasification 
combined-cycle" (IGCC) power plants to create electricity. Pennsylvania hopes 
to replace many of its filthy coal-fired power plants with IGCC plants.

"You could put a million scrubbers on an old coal-fired power plant and never 
even approach the environmental performance of a coal gasification plant," says 
Kathleen McGinty, secretary of Pennsylvania's Department of Environmental 
Protection. 

So those are the bennies: Pennsylvania reduces air pollutants, solves its 
waste-coal problem, boosts its economy, and gets a reputation as a clean-power, 
energy-independence leader. Not bad.

There are three drawbacks, and they are substantial:

If gasification takes off, there isn't enough waste coal in the country to feed 
the beast. Thus, you're back to coal mining, which is a nightmare. 

Gasification is largely untested and unproven, at least in the U.S. And IGCC 
plants are more expensive than old-fashioned dirty coal-fired plants. Thus, 
gasification relies heavily on subsidies. State and U.S. Dept. of Energy tax 
incentives for the Penn. plant, for instance, add up to over $140 million. More 
big industries getting chummy with gov't; more semi-permanent corporate welfare 
recipients. 

Carbon dioxide. Global warming. That whole thing. IGCC plants are certainly an 
improvement over dirty coal-fired plants -- they use less coal to create more 
energy -- but they still produce plenty of CO2. They do make the CO2 fairly 
easy to capture, which is nice, but the question is what to do with it once 
it's captured. The big idea is to sequester it: pump it underground or into 
plant tissues and soil. However: 

"The effectiveness of CO2 storage in those systems is completely unknown," says 
Anne Hedges, program director for the Montana Environmental Information Center. 
"It's a nice theory, and I sure hope it works. But there's absolutely no 
evidence it does on a long-term basis."

So that's a problem. 

In short, if you view coal gasification from the perspective of today's energy 
situation, it's an improvement. If you view it from the perspective of the 
optimal renewable-energy future, it's a big scam. ....."






 






________________________________________________________________________
AOL now offers free email to everyone.  Find out more about what's free from 
AOL at AOL.com.
_______________________________________________
RSS, archives, subscription & listserv information for:
[email protected]
http://lists.mutualaid.org/mailman/listinfo/sustainabletompkins
free hosting by http://www.mutualaid.org

Reply via email to