Jeanne -- I'm not so sure we disagree all that much. I don't think we should subsidize "liquid coal" production. I agree that it would be a disaster to develop coal as a source of liquid (or gaseous) fuel without addressing the CO2 impacts first, and I think we should impose a requirement that enough CO2 be sequestered somehow to offset its use compared to viable alternatives. From what I have been reading, a carbon tax might be a reasonable way to do that. I just don't see that the potential contributions of the alternatives will make more than a small dent in the problem of inadequate supply once we peak out in oil production. I think the various options to supplement oil should compete in the marketplace and prosper or not based on their merits. The government's role should be to facilitate research, up to and including demonstration plants. The government's role should also be to make sure that the environmental impacts are paid for in the cost of production and not "externalized" -- the worst form of subsidy. And then we should address the need to reduce greenhouse gas production with a carbon tax.
Joel At 03:11 PM 6/11/07 -0400, you wrote: >I strongly disagree with Joel.  Coal is by far the worst carbon dioxide >emitter as well as having hosts of other mining and pollutin problems. The >chances of sequestering the coal are by no more certain. According to a >chart published in The New York Times on May 29, 2007, the EPA estimates >that âusing liquefied coal as a fuel source could increase greenhouse >gas emissions 119 per cent over petroleum.     Sequestration could >supposedly reduce that to 4.5 % but as noted the technology is >questionable and far superior alternatives exist. It is an irresponsible >and insane proposal.   Liquified coal would also exacerbate the other >cost of coal mining (see very last paragraph).    Cellulosic ethanol, >Biodiesel and sugar ethanol are far superior choices as a liquid fuel >according to the NYT chart. (However the overrated corn-based  ethanol, >besides competing with food uses, is energy intensive and represents only >a 22 % improvement.)      Prodded By Industry Lobbying, >Self-Proclaimed Global Warming Opponents Now Pushing Coal        >  http://thinkprogress.org/2007/05/29/coal-warming/  Global carbon >dioxide emissions are now exceeding even the most âextremeâ >predictions, and 2007 is already the hottest year ever recorded. Yet even >as congressional leaders draft legislation to reduce greenhouse gases, >âa powerful roster of Democrats and Republicans is pushing to subsidize >coal as the king of alternative fuels.â Prodded by âintense lobbying >from the coal industry,â lawmakers from coal states are proposing that >taxpayers spend billions of dollars to subsidize the coal industryâs >production of liquid diesel fuel. This is a dangerously backwards idea. >Coal-to-liquid fuels âproduce almost twice the volume of greenhouse >gases as ordinary diesel,â and the production process of such fuels >âcreates almost a ton of carbon dioxide for every barrel of liquid >fuel.â Congressional supporters of coal-to-liquids argue that >âcoal-based fuels are more American than gasoline.â But the only >responsible way to achieve American energy independence is to create >policies that also reduce global warming, and that can be done with >low-carbon, American-grown alternative fuels. A profile in courage on this >issue is Sen. Jon Tester (D-MT), who this month killed a coal-to-liquids >proposal despite coming from a coal state. As Gristmillâs Dave Roberts >noted, Tester realizes âthat blundering ahead with coal before >addressing its emissions is tantamount to collective suicide, and heâs >not willing to sign on with that for the sake of a big-money industry in >his state.â More From Move-On Liquid coal is a giant step backward in >our fight against global warmingit produces twice as maany greenhouse >gases as conventional gasoline. Proposals to capture that pollution before >it adds to global warming are still a pipe dream.2 We have to reduce the >greenhouse gases already in our air to stave off the worst effects of >climate changedisease, drought, rising seasso so you'd think a giant >program to make liquid coal a cornerstone of our economy would be too >outrageous to consider. But continued pressure from the coal industry >means key legislators introduce it over and over again. Even the Roanoke >Times, in the heart of coal country, condemned government promotion of >liquid coal: Coal-to-liquid technology is expensive, harmful to the >environment and inefficient. The federal government should take no part in >subsidizing it...Liquefying coal is not the answer to either energy >independence or a cleaner environment.3 Some senators are standing strong >against this false promiseJon TTester from coal-rich Montana has said >there should be no liquid coal without proven ways to capture the >greenhouse gases.4 But others are risking our future with dirty energy >bills instead of supporting clean and affordable alternativeslike solar >and wind. 1. "Lawmakers Push for Big Subsidies for Coal Process," New >York Times, May 29, 2007 >http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/29/business/29coal.html 2. "Wrong path >toward energy independence," Denver Post, June 9, 2007 >http://www.denverpost.com/opinion/ci_6088295 3. "Billion Dollar >Boondoggle," Roanoke Times, June 5 2007 >http://www.roanoke.com/editorials/wb/119477 4. "Tester: Offer incentives >for carbon capture," Missoulian, June 2, 2007 >http://www.moveon.org/r?r=2654&id=10508-5159930-OA7T2f&t=4 >FromSaveOurEnvironment http://www.SaveOurEnvironment.org Have you heard >about liquid coal? It's a transportation fuel made from coal that is >expensive, inefficient, dirty, and releases large quantities of >heat-trapping carbon dioxide into our air. Despite these drawbacks, >however, Congress is getting ready to throw huge subsidies at the liquid >coal industry instead of investing those taxpayer dollars in efficient, >renewable energy that will help solve global warming and decrease our >dependence on oil. The considerable economic, social and environmental >drawbacks of coal-derived liquid fuel rule it out as a sound option to >help move America beyond oil. Relying on liquid coal as an alternative to >oil could nearly double global warming pollution per gallon of >transportation fuels! For example, using coal-based transportation fuel in >a Honda Civic would mean doubling the CO2 emissions, which would be >equivalent to operating a Hummer H3 run on conventional gasoline.* >Moreover, large-scale use of liquid coal would exacerbate the devastating >effects of coal mining felt by communities and ecosystems stretching from >Appalachia to the Rocky Mountains, including polluted air and water, >devastated landscapes and a dismal record of worker safety. Coal >gasification has a little better near-term potential but is still a scam >in the long run. An article from Grist follows in the next posting. The >United States has already done enough damage to the planet/world with >coal. China is now following suit at a breakneck pace But the U.S. as >the primary gluttonous culprit should just leave the bloody stuff in the >ground and help China to avoid the same insane path. Jeanne     >  -----Original Message----- From: Joel and Sarah Gagnon ><[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sustainable Tompkins County >listserv <[email protected]> Sent: Sat, 9 Jun 2007 >11:43 am Subject: Re: [SustainableTompkins] Obama You can't fight Global >warming With Coal I think we will need to use all available sources of >substitutes for oil nce demand exceeds supply. Coal can play a role if we >can limit its reenhouse gas impact. That may be possible if at least some >of the CO2 is equestered. Personally, I think we should be pressing to >make government upport contingent on doing that rather than pushing not to >use coal at all. Joel >________________________________________________________________________ >AOL now offers free email to everyone. Find out more about what's free >from AOL at AOL.com. _______________________________________________ RSS, >archives, subscription & listserv information for: >[email protected] >http://lists.mutualaid.org/mailman/listinfo/sustainabletompkins free >hosting by http://www.mutualaid.org _______________________________________________ RSS, archives, subscription & listserv information for: [email protected] http://lists.mutualaid.org/mailman/listinfo/sustainabletompkins free hosting by http://www.mutualaid.org
