According to a recent study, much of this discussion is moot.
Coal reserves have been vastly overstated, and most estimates of
coal as an energy source have missed the fact that the energy
content of the coal we've got here in the U.S. has been steadily
declining due to declining quality.  So while U.S. production of
coal by *volume* won't peak for another couple of decades, the
total *energy content* of annual US coal production peaked back in
1998.  See

    http://europe.theoildrum.com/node/2396

This doesn't mean that we won't rip up all the landscape we can in
an effort to keep the wheels turning; it just means that in the
larger scheme of things, it won't do any good.  That EROEI will
getcha every time.

Jon

Joel and Sarah Gagnon wrote:
> Jeanne --
> 
> I'm not so sure we disagree all that much. I don't think we should 
> subsidize "liquid coal" production. I agree that it would be a disaster to 
> develop coal as a source of liquid (or gaseous) fuel without addressing the 
> CO2 impacts first, and I think we should impose a requirement that enough 
> CO2 be sequestered somehow to offset its use compared to viable 
> alternatives. From what I have been reading, a carbon tax might be a 
> reasonable way to do that. I just don't see that the potential 
> contributions of the alternatives will make more than a small dent in the 
> problem of inadequate supply once we peak out in oil production. I think 
> the various options to supplement oil should compete in the marketplace and 
> prosper or not based on their merits. The government's role should be to 
> facilitate research, up to and including demonstration plants. The 
> government's role should also be to make sure that the environmental 
> impacts are paid for in the cost of production and not "externalized" -- 
> the worst form of subsidy. And then we should address the need to reduce 
> greenhouse gas production with a carbon tax.
> 
> Joel

_______________________________________________
RSS, archives, subscription & listserv information for:
[email protected]
http://lists.mutualaid.org/mailman/listinfo/sustainabletompkins
free hosting by http://www.mutualaid.org

Reply via email to