On 9/06/2015 5:07 AM, Ryan Feeley wrote:
Am I missing any states? Make sense?
Makes sense to me, and looks good!
Re the last page "Start doing <show reconnect hamburger menu>" and "Stop
doing <show reconnect as a bottom info-bar>"...
Note that we already do show a "reconnect" state in the hamburger menu -
so "start doing" should be "keep doing".
That infobar has a (deservedly) bad reputation, but mainly because it
sometimes lies (ie, asks you to reconnect when you haven't changed your
password) and also because of other unrelated error states that appear
("failed to Sync for 14 days", "could not connect to the server")
But I don't think we should throw the baby out with the bath water. We
need to avoid having these infobars appear when we don't expect them
(eg, the generic "can't sync" one) and we may also want to reconsider
the "can't sync for 14 days" message, but IMO it will be a mistake to
rely *only* on the hamburger menu for reporting states that require
immediate and direct user intervention - I don't believe people use the
hamburger menu enough with day-to-day browsing - many people will not
notice such a state until the next time they decide to print a page or
similar.
2c please ;)
Mark
_______________________________________________
Sync-dev mailing list
[email protected]
https://mail.mozilla.org/listinfo/sync-dev
