ASP: Depends on your shop. If you're a MS shop, then you'll go with ASP. Things do seem separated to the point where the reason for using ASP or SQL Server or some such is not through a choice about that particular product, but because the company are an MS shop. This is less a technical a decision than a business decision.
PHP: It is a bit dodgy security wise. It's also less corporate, so a poor business decision. It's pretty much platform independent though and not a bad choice if you're a small, non-MS startup wanting to get going quickly. I think saying PHP is not widely used is a bit off, but in corporate community, I'd definitely agree. One problem I have with PHP is a lack of the concept of a web-application. It's hard to share something between pages that belong to the same application without other applications getting that. ColdFusion: This has some advantages. Better integration for gfx/web designers. I think the new version of Flash is quite integrated into ColdFusion server, not sure if the same is true of JRun, I doubt it. I've never programmed with this so can't describe it too much. My worries would be: 1) Macromedia are a gfx company (to me) so can they support the kind of industry that Sun (to me a network company and a bit hardware, yeah I have an odd view) can. 2) Can CFML scope? My last contact with it was that it was just a buncha tags, whereas JSP Tags are just tags with Java behind them. Why Taglibs? Why Java in general? Taglibs are far more pliable than the three major alternatives we've described. You're not limited to the tag world, in fact I think the product at my company has a grand total of 1 jsp, and that's for automated testing that the system is up. The rest is servlets talked to in xml by flash. And yet we're still using Java. So the versatility is the major reason. Hen On Fri, 15 Mar 2002, Mader, Steve wrote: > > Here are some of my reasons: > > First, Jakarta tags are just taglibs, which are a part of the J2EE > architecture. This (J2EE) is a very portable and scaleable solution. > > ASP: Do you really have to ask. Microsoft products only run on Microsoft > platforms, thus they are not portable. > > PHP: These server side objects are interpreted, which always leads to > vulnerabilities. ( see CERT Advisory CA-2002-05 Multiple Vulnerabilities in > PHP fileupload at www.cert.org ). Plus they are not widely used. > > Cold Fusion: Does not do everything J2EE does (JSP's, Servlet's, JavaBeans, > JDBC, etc.), which is why Macromedia also has JRun. > > Hope this helps. > > -----Original Message----- > From: Bogesdorfer, Dan [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] > Sent: Friday, March 15, 2002 10:28 AM > To: 'Tag Libraries Users List' > Subject: OT: Seeking Opinions > > > I've been lurking for a few weeks and wanted to get some inputt from you > guys/girls. You can email me off list so as not to clog this list up if > needed. I'm looking for your reasons as to why your using this environment > (Jakarta tags..jsp) instead of using something like Microsoft's ASP, PHP, > Cold Fusion and the list goes on. > > Thanks.... > > Daniel Bogesdorfer > Senior Programmer / Analyst > Office Of Research Health Sciences > University of Pittsburgh > 412.648.2366 > > email: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > -- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: > <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > For additional commands, e-mail: > <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > -- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > For additional commands, e-mail: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> For additional commands, e-mail: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
