Hi, Matthias Julius wrote: > What I don't like here is that this leads to duplication of data. > Super-relations are fine, but IMHO tags should be moved to the > super-relation.
They should, but I would postpone that until later. The same is true with today's superways - tags should really be moved from the way into the relation but we can wait with that until everyone knows how to handle a superway. > What is an application actually supposed to do when the tagging of of > a relation contradicts the tagging of its members? For example: a > super-relation with "ref=E50" with a member-relation with "ref=E52" > which has a way tagged with "ref=E58" I guess in practice this will depend on the type of relation one is talking about. With superway-type relations, the leaf objects have precedence. Bye Frederik _______________________________________________ talk mailing list talk@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
