2009/8/10 John Smith <[email protected]>: > > --- On Mon, 10/8/09, Martin Simon <[email protected]> wrote: >> With path, you can distinguish between e.g. officially >> designated >> "footways" and those that have no designation at all. >> Furthermore, it is possible to tag combined >> cycle/foot/whateverways >> without discriminating one of the modes of transport. (like >> with >> "highway=cycleway, foot=yes" before) > > How do you propose to highlight the primary purpose?
In the case of a combinet cycle and footway in germany, there is no primary purpose, pedestrians and cyclists have equal rights on these ways. So I tag "highway=path,bicycle=designated,foot=designated". > Cyclists want to know the best cycle path, the fact that cycling is allowed > doesn't give enough information, and in fact by reducing these ways to a > simple path + allowed uses information would be lost. It's not about allowing cycling(like official fooways that _also_ allow bicycles as "guests"), it's about official designation. This makes, at least in Germany, a big (legal) difference... So you could tag a footway which also allows bicycles as highway=footway,bicycle=yes(assuming "footway" implies foot=designated) or as highway=path,foot=designated,bicycle=yes. No Information loss, no difference, no problem. :-) -Martin _______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

