John Smith wrote: > Forced is probably the wrong word, gamed the system is what I would have said.
The system was used exactly as it was intended. It's not my fault if few people choose to participate. > If there is over 100,000 accounts and at least 1% of them actively map and > have actively mapped for over 1 year 30 or 40 votes compared to a possible > 1000 participants isn't a very indicative outcome. We only reached 100,000 accounts this year. When the final vote was registered on highway=path (May 2008) we were at 35000 users. Not all of those who map also use the wiki regularly. Your "possible 1000 participants" is a very high estimate, I would say. Regardless... > The current system is flawed when it comes to making decisions on complex > issues, this is why democracies aren't democracies, nothing would ever be > decided if everyone had a vote on everything. Instead we have republics where > a few are elected or nominated to make the decisions. No arguments with this, but would would you have had us do? I'm pretty sure there'd be even more screaming if we'd just unilaterally changed the wiki. Do nothing? Despite some peoples' objections, it certainly does fill a need. If you have a proposal for a better system (and I'm pretty sure that doesn't include any kind of wiki masters who get to decide what's useful and what's not), I'm sure we'd be happy to hear it. -Alex Mauer "hawke"
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

