Roy Wallace <[email protected]> Sent by: [email protected] 10/08/2009 23:2
To Martin Simon <[email protected]> cc talk <[email protected]> Subject Re: [OSM-talk] Proliferation of path vs. footway On Mon, Aug 10, 2009 at 8:52 PM, Martin Simon<[email protected]> wrote: > So you could tag a footway which also allows bicycles as > highway=footway,bicycle=yes(assuming "footway" implies > foot=designated) The thing is though it doesn't necessary imply this. There are examples of highway=footway which are *private* paths not accessible legally to the public (or only through payment of an entrance fee) e.g. the paths within a paid-for tourist attraction (Marwell Zoo is a local example for me) or the paths on a private housing estate. > or as highway=path,foot=designated,bicycle=yes. No > Information loss, no difference, no problem. :-) TBH I'd deprecate "yes" because it's got too much ambiguity. Ask yourself: is there a *legal right* for that mode of transit to use that path, or is it at the discretion of the landowner (who could be a private landowner, or a council or government). If the former, use "designated". If the latter, use "permissive". So a paved (concrete) cycle path where cyclists have a legal right and pedestrians don't, could be highway=path; surface=paved; bicycle=designated; foot=no or if both have a legal right highway=path; surface=paved; bicycle=designated; foot=designated or if cyclists are allowed by an informal (and often retractable) permission of the landowner, whereas pedestrians have a legal right: highway=path; surface=paved; bicycle=permissive; foot=designated I believe that this would work anywhere in the world, as I would imagine that all modes of transit have either a right, an informal/retractable right, or no right to use a given way. Please correct me if I'm wrong though. Nick _______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

