Hi Masanobu and hi all! > Sent: Tuesday, May 23, 2017 at 6:18 AM > From: "Masanobu SAITOH" <msai...@execsw.org> > To: "Rocky Hotas" <rockyho...@post.com>, msai...@netbsd.org > Cc: msai...@execsw.org, tech-kern@netbsd.org > Subject: Re: Kernel code documentation and pci data structures (was: Problem > with Intel WiFi card) > > It's one of the thing that I want to have it in our ppb.c. > I'd like to add PCI(e) hot-plug stuff because of nvme(4) > hot-plug. Reasons why I've not doing the work yet are that > I'm now working another job(fixing bugs in ixg(4) and wm(4)) > and I'm not familiar with resource allocation near here :-(
I can understand you. Moreover, it is difficult as I was saying to get documented about it. > I think it's worth for you to > read sys/dev/pci/pciconf.c Thank you, I'll try. > Did you check the PCI config area of ppb"1" on your machine? > iwn0 is under ppb1. Yes and it is not configured, as expected. The base/limit registers of the "I/O", "Memory" and "Prefetchable memory" regions are left configured, while instead the code in OpenBSD manages them. > Could you show me the output of "pcictl pciN dump" of your ppb1? You can find it here: https://pastebin.com/bkwXMuxX > And, If you are OK, could you me the full output of pcictl > using with the following script? > > http://www.netbsd.org/~msaitoh/pcidump > Yes, no problem. I had some issue to upload it, though. These are two options: 1) http://www119.zippyshare.com/v/DUR50NZw/file.html (It is a page from where the file can be downloaded: I tried and it worked, but be careful: a pop-up or similar can be opened!) 2) https://www.sendspace.com/file/ddnvqd (I tried here also, and it worked, without popups) Both should expire after 30 days of no use. For further information: I re-compiled the kernel today (it is -current, version 7.99.73), with options PCIVERBOSE options PCI_CONFIG_DUMP options MSGBUFSIZE=262144 and here is the content of `/var/run/dmesg.boot' about ppb1: https://pastebin.com/zaACgZXf (unfortunately the dmesg was not entirely recorded, despite the huge MSGBUFSIZE, but the interesting part here has been saved). In particular, notice that I/O region: base register: 0x00 limit register: 0x00 ... Memory region: base register: 0x0000 limit register: 0x0000 .... Prefetchable memory region: base register: 0x0001 limit register: 0x0001 as anticipated. If it can be useful, this is the dump of Configuration Space in Linux of the same ppb: https://pastebin.com/pFbcMWYp (in human-readable form) https://pastebin.com/d3xCKjCZ (full, in hexadecimal) In Linux, this WiFi card (and the associated ppb) works. Sorry for my delay, it took a while to get all these files. Thank you for your reply! Rocky > Regards. > > -- > ----------------------------------------------- > SAITOH Masanobu (msai...@execsw.org > msai...@netbsd.org) >