Wow.... that's a lot coming from you today.  You eat chocolate AND coffee 
today ?  :-)

Direct lightning strike, I'm with the original poster, nothing will stop a 
direct strike.  You almost never have a direct strike on your equipment, and 
the electric grid tries to protect itself from such hits, but isn't designed 
to protect all the users equipment as much as it is the grid itself.

How do I know ?  I work for the 'lectric company !

When the blackout occurred in Florida a couple years ago, we saw transient 
voltages and frequencies as far north as New England, far beyond the actual 
blackout area.  All that happened in Florida that day was an engineer 
defeated protective systems on a switch, and when a fault occurred in the 
substation, the systems that were designed to protect it couldn't, and then 
other backup systems had to, but operate slower, which allowed the problem 
to propagate farther out rather than be contained.  Slower is a relative 
term, which may mean 1/4 or 1/2 second, normally protection systems operate 
within a few cycles, meaning 1/20th of a second or so.

Lightning strikes are protected by, of all things, lightning arrestors, 
which are a straight path to ground when the voltage on the line goes up 
beyond the normal range.  It goes from being a high resistance to almost no 
resistance reacting directly to the voltage spike itself.  Also, over the 
high voltage power lines are what they call "static wires" which among other 
things, tries to intercept the lightning strikes, keeping it from hitting 
the power wires directly.  At the distribution level, I don't know what they 
have there, but I'd expect similar equipment, but since the voltage has to 
go up for the device to operate, you will see spikes, no matter how well 
they work.  A direct hit to the circuit you're on will likely send some big 
voltage swings into your house, which may or may not upset equipment.

My folks had a lightning strike on a palm tree outside the house, it 
followed the tree down, jumped to the sprinkler wires, into the house, onto 
the telephone system, and fried a TV set, the TiVo modem on their S1 box, 
and a few other things.  The most spectacular part of it besides the burned 
up tree, scattered stones, and the very skittish cat was one power 
transformer which was plugged into an outlet exploded, sending plastic 
fragments around the room, embedding in boxes 20' away with significant 
force.

See, there was even Tivo content in the message  :-)

For what it's worth, I know my company offers whole house protection, not in 
terms of UPS, but for voltage spikes, which while a little expensive, 
protects everything in the house, and is generally quality equipment.  If 
you really want to protect everything, that's not a bad way to go.

Glen

----- Original Message ----- 
From: "MegaZone" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: <[email protected]>
Sent: Saturday, September 27, 2008 8:53 PM
Subject: Re: [TiVo Central] Re: Surge Protectors


> Once upon a time m_jessing shaped the electrons to say...
>> Two things to keep in mind - UPS' are for computers, surge suppressors
>> are for TV's etc.  UPS systems are designed for computers so in the
>
> That's not really true...... 

Reply via email to