R Johnson;517715 Wrote: 
> Quite a few classical downloads are available in 24/88.2 format.

You have to ask what equipment was used to RECORD this music.  If the
recordings are more than about 20 years old, a higher bit rate and
sample rate won't help because the original recording equipment did not
have the required fidelity.  

For example, I found a company on the internet that claims to sell high
definition recordings of Rachmaninoff (who died in 1943).  The claims
are nonsensical.  The explanation on the website mixes up issues of midi
and audio to the point of being preposterous.  Yes, Rachmaninoff
recorded piano rolls.  But piano rolls had no velocity information thus
you are not getting Rachmaninoff if piano rolls are what that company is
using.

And I wouldn't assume that music recorded within the last 20 years can
be purchased at a higher fidelity just because the download is available
in a higher fidelity format.  The purchaser has to inquire as to the
recording process (analog vs digital; what digital, what microphones,
what studio, if the producer made the master available to the
distributor, etc.).

And don't assume that just because the music was recorded on analog
tape that this will yield higher fidelity digital quality.  You have to
understand the evolution of the technology of analog tape recorders and
know that even today they are constantly evolving in their quality (by
the very few companies left in the field).

My general impression is that searching for music in a higer fidelity
format for the sake of higher fidelity is compromising the listener's
choice of music.


-- 
mortslim
------------------------------------------------------------------------
mortslim's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=11039
View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=74688

_______________________________________________
Touch mailing list
Touch@lists.slimdevices.com
http://lists.slimdevices.com/mailman/listinfo/touch

Reply via email to