On 8/14/07, Jean-Sebastien Delfino <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > ant elder wrote: > > On 8/14/07, Jean-Sebastien Delfino <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > >> Anderson, Jeff T (CA - Toronto) wrote: > >> > >>> I like having the samples, in the absence of extensive documentation > >>> > >> these are key to understanding Tuscany... > >> > >>> I like the idea of packaging the samples as simple SCA contribution > >>> > >> jar's. I think keeping the footprint as little as possible is > important, > >> both in terms of optics and managing the complexity and understanding. > >> > >>> Just my humble opinion... > >>> Jeff > >>> > >>> > >>> > >> +1 to keep the samples as simple SCA contribution JARs. > >> > >> The current webapp packaging is not quite right anyway as it's > >> introducing a half baked mix of J2EE and SCA programming model inside > >> the webapp. > >> > >> I'd suggest the following: > >> > >> - Package SCA sample components as simple SCA contribution JARs, stay > >> away from webapps. > >> > >> - To allow JSP and servlets to invoke SCA service component, support > >> <implementation.web> Web components as described in [1]. > >> > >> [1] http://www.osoa.org/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=3980 > >> > > > > > > (now back on the dev list) > > > > Just to make sure I understand, as an example right now we have > > sample-helloworld-ws-service and sample-helloworld-ws-service-webapp, do > we > > just delete the -webapp one? > > Yes > > > And then you can use the jar built by the > > sample-helloworld-ws-service with either the the Geronimo/Tuscany > > integration or our webapp runtime or with the standalone runtime we > already > > use it with today? > > > > That sounds like the way to go to me but that seems like quite a big > change, > > do we want to try to get this done in time for the upcoming release or > wait > > till after that and just make the changes for 1.0? > > > > ...ant > > > > > > I prefer to do it now. I'm not quite sure why it's a big change? > > Isn't it just about deleting Maven modules? we have equivalent samples > already working with the standalone runtime right? > > Is the Geronimo integration ready to be included in the the release? > > -- > Jean-Sebastien
I also think sooner would be better so happy to help go for it. The list of current webapps is: demo-alert-aggregator demo-mortgage-creditcheck sample-calculator-webapp sample-chat-webapp sample-helloworld-dojo sample-helloworld-jsonrpc sample-helloworld-ws-sdo-webapp sample-helloworld-ws-service-webapp Not sure we do have equivalent non-webapp samples for all those, i'll have a go at and seeing if they all those sample- ones run ok out side of a webapp. ..ant
