(no name) via tz wrote:

> I don't know why some seem to be so judgemental about this.

I know why I’m judgmental about it.

I was there in 1974 when the US went on permanent DST. It was already not 
popular where I lived, possibly because — as mentioned elsewhere — the choice 
of January 6 to switch back to DST maximized the late-sunrise jolt, and because 
my location in Southern California (east of the 120° meridian, and far enough 
south to minimize seasonal day-length change) was already well-positioned for 
standard time.

It became less popular as late sunrises carried on for months (almost 8 am in 
early January, not receding to 7 am until mid-March), and when reports spread 
of accidents involving kids walking to schools or bus stops in darkness. There 
wasn’t much that needed to be “sensationalized” about that.

Today we hear that “life is different today” and that the failure of the 1974 
experiment is no longer relevant. In a way that’s true. We have many more 
clocks now that switch automatically to and from DST, reducing the burden of 
going around the house and changing them manually. Air travel across time zones 
is more common today, bringing shifts of one or more hours to more people’s 
sleep cycles.

But some things have not changed: many people still commute to work in the 
morning, and kids still physically go to school (remember the outcry during the 
pandemic when schools went online?). More parents do drive their kids to school 
than 50 years ago, which means more predawn car traffic if schools start in 
darkness.

And winter is still winter — more so in many places than in Southern 
California. Days are shorter in winter than in summer! No reasonable amount of 
clock-shifting will bring back 8:30 pm sunsets during winter, and even if it 
did, winter weather in much of North America is simply not amenable to 
early-evening golf, backyard barbecues, and other summery outdoor activities 
that permanent DST is promised to enable. Most people like evening daylight (I 
certainly do), but year-round summer time will not bring year-round summer.

About the only thing that is different, that lends itself to permanent DST, is 
that we seem far less tolerant of minor inconveniences. We went along for 
decades, occasionally grumbling about having to change the clocks, lose an hour 
of sleep once a year, etc. but carrying on with our lives. Now, suddenly in the 
last 8 or 10 years, standard time and clock-switching have apparently become 
these terrible, life-ruining things.

I expect the US to move to permanent DST before long, and I look forward to the 
backlash when reality sets in. It will remind me of my childhood.

--
Doug Ewell, CC, ALB | Lakewood, CO, US | ewellic.org


Reply via email to