The question was, when do Michigan, Spain, France, and Saskatchewan - who moved 
to daylight time in the winter decades ago, move back to their local solar 
standard time?

I wasn't looking for a TLDR diatribe about foreign politics a couple of 
generations ago.

Doug Ewell wrote:
> (no name) via tz wrote:
> > I don't know why some seem to be so judgemental about this.
> > I know why I’m judgmental about it.
> 
> I was there in 1974 when the US went on permanent DST. It was already not 
> popular where I lived, possibly because — as mentioned elsewhere — the choice 
> of January 6 to switch back to DST maximized the late-sunrise jolt, and 
> because my location in Southern California (east of the 120° meridian, and 
> far enough south to minimize seasonal day-length change) was already 
> well-positioned for standard time.
> 
> It became less popular as late sunrises carried on for months (almost 8 am in 
> early January, not receding to 7 am until mid-March), and when reports spread 
> of accidents involving kids walking to schools or bus stops in darkness. 
> There wasn’t much that needed to be “sensationalized” about that.
> 
> Today we hear that “life is different today” and that the failure of the 1974 
> experiment is no longer relevant. In a way that’s true. We have many more 
> clocks now that switch automatically to and from DST, reducing the burden of 
> going around the house and changing them manually. Air travel across time 
> zones is more common today, bringing shifts of one or more hours to more 
> people’s sleep cycles.
> 
> But some things have not changed: many people still commute to work in the 
> morning, and kids still physically go to school (remember the outcry during 
> the pandemic when schools went online?). More parents do drive their kids to 
> school than 50 years ago, which means more predawn car traffic if schools 
> start in darkness.
> 
> And winter is still winter — more so in many places than in Southern 
> California. Days are shorter in winter than in summer! No reasonable amount 
> of clock-shifting will bring back 8:30 pm sunsets during winter, and even if 
> it did, winter weather in much of North America is simply not amenable to 
> early-evening golf, backyard barbecues, and other summery outdoor activities 
> that permanent DST is promised to enable. Most people like evening daylight 
> (I certainly do), but year-round summer time will not bring year-round summer.
> 
> About the only thing that is different, that lends itself to permanent DST, 
> is that we seem far less tolerant of minor inconveniences. We went along for 
> decades, occasionally grumbling about having to change the clocks, lose an 
> hour of sleep once a year, etc. but carrying on with our lives. Now, suddenly 
> in the last 8 or 10 years, standard time and clock-switching have apparently 
> become these terrible, life-ruining things.
> 
> I expect the US to move to permanent DST before long, and I look forward to 
> the backlash when reality sets in. It will remind me of my childhood.
> 
> --
> Doug Ewell, CC, ALB | Lakewood, CO, US | ewellic.org

Reply via email to