For the record, I just want to say the decision to stick with Daylight Savings by government is generally a stupid decision and objectively unsupported by the science related to sleep, circadian rhythms, driving safety etc etc. It is an industry friendly decision. The public in BC specifically overwhelmingly wanted the changing of times to stop. They were not asked on standard vs daylight.
But that is all very much beside the point and the reason I am here is solely because my server will confuse the general public if it reports MST rather than PCT or PDT in its output and that, to my understanding, is the mandate of tzdata; to produce an output that is in sync with the expectation of the population and body politik writ large in the affected region. Cheers Chris > On Nov 19, 2026, at 12:27, Brooks Harris via tz <[email protected]> wrote: > > >> On 2026-11-18 08:10 PM, via tz wrote: >> kc0bmzd14@mozmail.com wrote: >>> Numeric time seems best until Canada gets their stuff straight (or the U.S. >>> abolishes clock switching too). >> Canada has no control, and nothing to do with it. It's 100% in the realm of >> the provinces, constitutionally. And that constitution is very difficult to >> change. Well, 13 really, as Canada is unlikely to invoke their rights over >> time in the territories, over such a trivia matter. >> >> Think of it as 10 different sovereign countries, with such strong >> constitutional powers (part of the reason that we might have free trade with >> the USA (supposedly), but not between provinces. >> >> Brooks Harris wrote: >>> ... when Canadians find themselves waking in the pitch dark >>> and reverse their "permanent daylight saving" decision, as happened in >>> the USA in 1974. >> I don't know why that would happen. It might push some locales to shift to a >> time zone further west, if they are near or already over, the western >> boundary of a time zone. Thunder Bay and Northwestern Ontario comes to mind. >> And as we've already seen in southwest Alberta. >> >> Saskatchewan went to permanent daylight time 60 years ago, it hasn't >> switched. France and Germany effectively moved to Daylight time in the >> winter and double daylight time in the summer, when they switched from GMT >> to GMT+1 in the 1940s. As did Michigan which mostly switched from Central to >> Eastern in the 1930s (Detroit switched during WW1, and even the upper >> peninsular in the 1970s. >> >> When is Michigan switching back to Central - almost a century of getting up >> in the dark. I don't know why some seem to be so judgemental about this. > I've always found it amusing that if you start talking about intricacies of > timekeeping, like TAI, UTC, leap-seconds, atomic clocks, even about time > zones in general, normal people, (not time nuts) will leave the conversation > as soon as possible. But if you speak about daylight saving *everybody* has > an opinion, from irritation, to questions of "why?", to expression of why > they do or do not like it, to anger with government decisions, to frustration > with the topic. Lots of judgements, few are the same. Time nuts have opinions > too, and not just about daylight saving.
