so there is no solution satisfy all

I agree entirely.

finally *that* is no valid reason for mail duplicates

Equally, it is not a valid reason to filter them. We need to recognise
people and communities are different, that both behaviours are useful,
and valid, and that people who want one kind of behaviour or another are
not stupid.

the reason someone has sieve filters for lists is that he want
filter out list-traffic and not mix it with business email
which has a completly different priority in read

Except if a list reply is directly relevant to him, in which case he
hopes, or even asks, the list to explicitly CC him on any replies so
they come to his inbox as higher priority mail.

then he knows the subject and filters *that* thread
so what

If he does this regularly, this is a high-effort option he probably does
not want to take. It's possible, but it's suboptimal. There is nothing
wrong with him wanting to do it differently.

In Thunderbird, the "Reply All" button turns into a "Reply List"
button when a mailing list is detected

no, i have three buttons

   * reply
   * reply-all
   * reply-list

guess why - because it are 3 different actions and reasons

Screen shot attached for your examination.

I don't know why it is different; maybe because my screen is smaller
than yours, or because the platform is different

because i take the time to configure my software
in mozilla products you can configure your toolbar simple by drag&drop

Well that tells us absolutely nothing about what I wrote about, which
was the trends in mail clients, does it?

I agree with you though, it makes sense for them to be separate. I
usually use the keyboard shortcuts, which are separate.

Best regards,

Ben.



_______________________________________________
Roundcube Users mailing list
users@lists.roundcube.net
http://lists.roundcube.net/mailman/listinfo/users

Reply via email to