On 28.10.23 14:09, Laszlo Kishalmi wrote:
On 10/28/23 04:52, Neil C Smith wrote:
On Sat, 28 Oct 2023, 12:29 Neil C Smith, <neilcsm...@apache.org> wrote:
On Sat, 28 Oct 2023, 11:59 Laszlo Kishalmi,
<laszlo.kisha...@gmail.com> wrote:
It would be good if somebody could test the Mouse Button
layouts on
Windows and Mac, probably can remove the MOUSE_BUTTON4 and
MOUSE_BUTTON5
registration...
They weren't added by accident! ;-)
I have all 3 OS to hand, and tested this on all 3. As far as I
could tell, buttons 4 & 5 are required for Mac and Windows. Linux
is the odd one out here, unfortunately.
Personally, my Wayland laptop trackpad doesn't show this issue.
We don't have an option to have disabled mappings. If the reports
are more than a one off issue, then the only option is really to
remove all the default mouse button mappings for NB20 and let
people configure them if they want. But it's not very
discoverable, and leaves the original feature request still
unfulfilled.
PS. Also, if you look at this comment you'll notice that Michael and
I had a conversation on the PR about xev values and the JDK numbers
being two lower because of scroll wheel events
https://github.com/apache/netbeans/pull/6434#issuecomment-1715252021
If we are 100% sure that 4&5 (native 6&7) map to horizontal scroll,
we could drop the value down another two in the event handler to
bring all OS in line?
That what I am thinking about! I think that would be safe to do, or
introduce a MOUSE_WHEEL_LEFT and MOUSE_WHEEL_RIGHT for those buttons
and map the rest with two down on Linux.
can confirm that mouse wheel left/right is button 4/5 on my mouse on
linux (swing event numbers, which are not the button numbers i see via
piper or xev)
back/forward is 6/7
(Thumb button would be 8 and a second set of forward/back is 9/10 but
most mice with a lot of buttons will probably map those by default to a
hardware or system function, e.g mouse resolution switch or volume
control etc - thats when the "standardization" ends most likely)
have nothing to swipe unfortunately so I can't help there :)
-mbien
Best wishes,
Neil
