>> You say we have absolutely no idea what sort of barring arrangement
>> violas might have had. But surely  we - or makers like you - do have
>> some idea. Some violas look very similar to vihuelas, and were made at
>> roughly the same time, and not geographically distant and play the same
>> sort of sophisticated, polyphonic music. It would at least be reasonable
> 
>> Or, do you think there is a possibility that violas had la much more
>> complicated lute-like barring?
>>
>> (Or, Monica-style; we just don't know, will never know and it's all
>> (mere?) speculation... )
> 
> Oh dear - I hope I don't sound too negative, but I am always sceptical of
> elaborate theories which are based on unprovable hypotheses.........
> 
> Monica
I am not.
RT



To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

Reply via email to