Bob wrote: | It would appear the generation of Li-7 from Li-6 or Li-6 from Li-7 | are reversed in the Lugano and Parkhomov experiments. Am I missing | something?
Bob, we are still not sure what “Sample 1”, “Sample 2” & “Natural State” represent in the Parkhomov Data. Sheet 1 is the Parkhomov Elemental Analysis via SIMS? (this hasn’t been fully verified) and what is located in the table on Sheet 2, is the Parkhomov ICP-MS Analysis. Everything outside the table/box are from Wikipedia or the Lugano Report found here for comparison: http://www.elforsk.se/Global/Omv%C3%A4rld_system/filer/LuganoReportSubmit.pdf Arnaud has suggested that instead of “Sample 1” & “Sample 2” being Ash Analysis for 2 different runs or parts of a run, “Sample 1” is the Fuel Analysis and “Sample 2” is the “Ash Analysis”. If that’s the case (and it seems to fit with what you just discovered above, then “Natural State” is not the Starting Fuel Analysis but an Analysis done on some sample taken to represent Natural Abundances, independently. This would also tend to agree with the analysis reported in the Lugano Paper. If I discover anything differently than this, I will report it here. Once again, the latest Spreadsheet with all the data collected together, is here: http://tinyurl.com/nz4gjdh Thanks, Mark Jurich
